Recent Posts — Expanded version

  • Behavioral Economics

    Behavioral economics combines psychology with economic theory, acknowledging that human decision-making is influenced by biases, emotions, and social factors. It explores heuristics, biases, Prospect Theory, nudges, and social preferences. Insights from behavioral economics have positively impacted policy in retirement savings, public health, energy conservation, education, and tax compliance. Behavioral economics has deepened…

  • Homo Economicus

    The recent shift in economic theory away from Homo Economicus acknowledges human decision-making complexity, leading to the development of Homo Socioeconomicus. This model incorporates social, emotional, and psychological factors, challenging the rational actor assumption. It presents challenges in modeling due to qualitative variables and cultural variability. Cultural influences significantly impact economic behaviors,…

  • Economic Stability

    Most economists agree on the minimal conditions for a stable economy, including low and stable inflation, sustainable public debt, effective regulation of financial institutions, healthy employment levels, stable political environment, balanced trade and current account, flexible and competitive market structures, and sound monetary policy. High economic predictability is deemed crucial for investment…

  • Divine Command Theory

    The content discusses Divine Command Theory (DCT) and its implications for morality, highlighting the challenges and tensions it raises. It explores the relationship between divine will and morality, the role of human moral intuition, and the philosophical and theological implications of conflicts between divine commands and moral intuitions. The discussion also delves…

  • Hard vs Soft Sciences

    The continuum from hard to soft sciences illustrates a shift from highly controlled, quantitative methodologies to more interpretative, qualitative approaches. This transition includes a progression from physics to chemistry, from biology to psychology, and from social sciences to humanities. As the categories move towards soft sciences, the complexity and degrees of freedom…

  • Perverse Incentives

    Perverse incentives lead to unintended and undesired outcomes by encouraging harmful behavior. Historical examples include the Cobra Effect in India and the Great Sparrow Campaign in China. Principles to mitigate perverse incentives include thorough impact assessment, feedback loops, and ethical considerations. Strategies to identify and quarantine bad actors involve data analytics, user…

  • What are Pseudosciences?

    Pseudoscience refers to beliefs or practices falsely presented as scientific, lacking empirical support, resisting testing or revision. Astrology, alchemy, homeopathy, and others are classified as pseudosciences due to their lack of adherence to scientific principles. They could become actual sciences by employing rigorous methodologies and empirical evidence. Pseudosciences attract individuals through simple…

  • The Power of Convergence

    The convergence of many lines of evidence in support of a theory is powerful because it indicates robustness, reduces bias, increases confidence, and enhances predictive power. This convergence is exemplified in the theory of biological evolution, supported by fossil records, comparative anatomy, molecular biology, biogeography, embryology, observations of natural selection, and experimental…

  • Innovation Attractors

    The innovation that powers top economies “clumps” in certain regions under specific conditions. Cultural, economic, and political factors create a fertile ground for high innovation, including risk-taking culture, predictability in business, resilience mechanisms, academic support, robust infrastructure, fiscal incentives, and more.

  • Selective Pressures on Ideologies

    The popularity of ideologies can often be attributed to factors unrelated to their inherent truth or ethical correctness, shaping societal norms and driving dominance. Emotional resonance, charismatic leaders, enemy construction, and simple solutions are reasons ideologies gain traction. 5 flawed ideologies include Manifest Destiny, White Man’s Burden, Fascism, Communism, and cults of…

  • Starting with Strong Basics

    Developing a proper epistemology early in life is crucial for shaping mental trajectory. It influences critical thinking, independent learning, open-mindedness, resilience to misinformation, and ethical responsibility. Analogies liken it to building a strong foundation, navigating through fog with a compass, and planting a garden with heirloom seeds. Early flaws in epistemology can…

  • Could Mind be Fundamental?

    The question of whether mind or consciousness is more fundamental than material reality has been a central debate in metaphysics. Various schools of thought offer different perspectives: – Materialism: The material world is fundamental, and consciousness arises from physical processes. – Idealism: Consciousness is fundamental; the material world is a mental construct.…

  • What is Consciousness?

    Consciousness is the state of being aware of and responsive to one’s surroundings, thoughts, and feelings. There are degrees of consciousness among sentient species, and human consciousness can vary in depth and quality due to sleep, intoxication, and other factors. Full human consciousness encompasses cognitive, emotional, self-reflective, and integrative features, setting it…

  • The Use of Proxies

    Some phenomena cannot be directly measured by science. Proxies, or indirect methods, are used to assess them. Examples across different fields include past climate reconstruction, black hole detection, economic well-being measurement, animal intelligence assessment, and ancient diet inference.

  • Asymmetric Counterfactuals

    The asymmetry in historical assessments arises from an emphasis on actual events over potential outcomes. This bias can lead to an overestimation of predictability and a neglect of alternative scenarios. Burying counterfactuals under the salience of the actual can negatively affect rationality, hindering critical thinking and decision-making. Strategies to mitigate this include…

  • Orthogonality

    Orthogonality in scientific research refers to the independence or non-overlapping nature of variables, methods, or evidence. It is commonly established through factorial designs, randomization, statistical tests, and methodological diversity. An example of robustly establishing orthogonality is a 2×2 factorial design in a clinical trial setting, examining the effects of two independent treatments.…

  • Calculating Risks

    The interplay between human emotions and faulty cognitive skills significantly impact risk assessment. Psychological biases such as availability heuristic, negativity bias, optimism bias, confirmation bias, affect heuristic, and misunderstanding of statistics distort our perception of danger. These biases are influenced by fear, overconfidence, and social pressures, leading to inaccurate risk assessments.

  • 1 at 99.5% or 5 at 95%?

    This article explores the mathematical equivalence between deep specialization in one skill and broad competency in multiple skills. It delves into the merits of focusing intensely on mastering one skill versus learning to a respectable level in several skills, offering balanced insight into the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches in different…

  • What is Falsifiability?

    Falsifiability, introduced by Karl Popper, requires scientific theories to be disprovable. It distinguishes scientific theories from non-scientific claims. Examples include the Heliocentric Model and the Peptic Ulcer Disease Hypothesis. Limitations include its application to complex theories and historical sciences. Critics argue for a balance of falsification and verification in scientific progress.

  • What is Parsimony?

    Parsimony, or Occam’s Razor, is a principle in the philosophy of science favoring simpler explanations with fewer assumptions. It guides scientific inquiry by promoting clarity, efficiency, and predictive power. Examples of complex yet internally consistent scientific theories and historical events demonstrate the value of parsimony in scientific progress and historical analysis. The…

  • Connotative Equivocation

    The tactic of manipulating public discourse through strategic language choices has been evident in historical cases such as the rebranding of “estate tax” to “death tax” for public opinion sway. In legal contexts, the choice between close synonyms like “young man” and “child” can impact the perception and judgment of the defendant.…

  • Dangers: Vested Interests

    Ideologies often create a vested interest by demanding significant time, financial contributions, emotional dependence, and limiting critical thinking. Employing critical thinking strategies, we can dismiss ideologies that claim truth requires immense investment by evaluating evidence, logical consistency, and considering historical and cultural context. Historical examples include Nikola Tesla’s obsession and the Salem…

  • Feedback Loops

    Feedback loops in knowledge acquisition play a crucial role for both human minds and AI. They enable continuous improvement, adaptation, and refinement of learning strategies and outcomes. In human minds, feedback facilitates personal growth, motivates learners, and refines educational systems. AI systems use feedback for machine learning, personalization, and error correction. The…

  • False Equivalencies

    False equivalencies occur when two opposing arguments or situations are presented as directly comparable, despite significant differences. Here are five examples: slavery and wage labor, climate change denial, fascism and anti-fascism movements, colonialism and post-colonial immigration, and the civil rights movement and white supremacist movement. These examples show how false equivalencies distort…

  • Human Reaction to AI

    The common progression of human reactions to new technology typically involves excitement, skepticism, adaptation, and integration. However, AI’s potential to surpass human intelligence, its opaqueness, and its wide-reaching impact present unique challenges. AI might trigger negative psychological effects, requiring strategies such as lifelong learning and ethical frameworks. The “black box” nature of…

  • AI Meta-Post – Inner Monologues

    The development of AI models capable of generating inner monologues represents a significant advancement in the field of artificial intelligence, particularly in the pursuit of clearer and deeper reasoning. Inner monologues, essentially a form of “thinking out loud” internally, play a crucial role in human cognitive processes. Here’s why they may be…

  • Economic Optimism

    The evidence for an upward economic trajectory includes historical GDP growth, reduction in global poverty, technological advancements, globalization, improvements in health and education, sustainability, and an increasing global middle class. Income inequality, job security, environmental concerns, globalization, psychological factors, and media influence contribute to economic pessimism. Public-facing economists and social scientists can…

  • Free Will vs Determinism

    The debate on free will encompasses diverse viewpoints: libertarian free will, hard determinism, compatibilism, hard incompatibilism, and skepticism. Philosophers lean towards compatibilism or skepticism, while cognitive scientists and psychologists study the impact of beliefs in free will on behavior. Neuroscientists focus on brain mechanisms and theoretical perspectives vary within and across disciplines.

  • Dualism vs Materialism

    The dialogue explores dualism and materialism through a captivating conversation between Maya and Daniel. Dualism emphasizes non-physical consciousness, citing qualia and near-death experiences, while materialism counters with neuroscientific evidence and the principle of causal closure. These core arguments are further dissected and organized into a comprehensive summary and a table for easy…

  • Science vs Subjectivity

    Minimizing subjectivity in science involves rigorous tools and methods. Standardized measurement instruments ensure consistent data collection, while blinding techniques prevent biases. Bayesian statistics and pre-registration enhance objectivity. Advancements in peer review and automation also contribute. Despite these advancements, complete elimination of subjectivity remains a challenge.

  • The Value of Surveys

    Surveys and whistleblower reports have led to significant changes across various sectors, uncovering important truths and driving improvements. Real-life accounts include TechJury’s marketing shift, Castorama’s service improvement, Looka’s ROI increase, and cases of whistleblowing in Russia, Serbia, and Nigeria. Bias in surveys can arise from sampling, question wording, response tendencies, and cultural…

  • Pascal’s Wager

    Pascal’s Wager, proposed by Blaise Pascal, argues for belief in God as a rational choice. It suggests that the potential gains of belief outweigh the potential losses. The wager does not require evidence for its weight, but it faces criticism for the “Which God?” problem and potential emotional manipulation. The logical or…

  • Presuppositions?

    The concept of inductive density refers to the degree or frequency with which our inductive reasoning processes encounter regularity or consistency in observed phenomena. This regularity strengthens our confidence and this confidence can approach, but never reach, absolute certainty due to the subjective nature of human minds. It underlines the limits of…

  • Neuroscience and Philosophy

    Neuroscience and philosophy intersect in exploring consciousness, free will, personal identity, ethics, perception, and knowledge. Agreement exists on the physical basis of the mind and importance of empirical evidence, while disagreement arises on the nature of consciousness, free will, the self, and qualia. Neuroscience’s new frontiers include connectomics, neuroplasticity, AI integration, and…

  • Micro/Macro Economics

    This post explores the differences between macro and microeconomics, micro and macroeconomic factors for a COO of a 100-employee company, essential macroeconomic concepts, essential microeconomic concepts, a quiz on the topics, and discussion questions. It emphasizes the importance of understanding both macro and microeconomic concepts for business decision-making. Topics include GDP, inflation,…

  • Psychology and Philosophy

    Philosophy of Mind focuses on the fundamental nature of the mind, while Psychology studies how the mind works in everyday life. Psychology employs empirical and scientific methods, while Philosophy of Mind relies on logic and thought experiments. Significant disagreements within these fields include the nature of consciousness, free will, the mind-body problem,…

  • What is “Design Thinking”?

    Design thinking is a user-centered approach to problem-solving, emphasizing empathy, collaboration, and experimentation across five main stages: Empathize, Define, Ideate, Prototype, and Test. It’s widely applicable, with successful implementations in product design, healthcare, education, technology, urban planning, and more. Hypothetical case studies and personal life applications demonstrate its versatility and impact.

  • Where are our Thoughts?

    The claim that thoughts must exist in a spiritual realm because they can’t be found in the brain is faulty because thoughts are the result of complex electrochemical processes, not physically observable entities. The analogy of a computer highlights that thoughts are processes, not physical things. The concept of physicalism, which explains…

  • The Status of Evil

    This exercise explores the legitimacy of attributing evil to a distinct ontological domain of morality. It questions whether emotional abhorrence alone justifies this or if other criteria are needed. The discussion covers critical evaluation strategies and implications on moral philosophy, delving into the role of emotions, cultural influences, and the necessity of…

  • Ontological Domains

    The provided content outlines a comprehensive list of proposed ontological domains and their dependencies, discusses the role of parsimony in avoiding a bloated ontology, provides questions for admitting new domains into an ontology, and includes a quiz and discussion prompts. It emphasizes the importance of empirical evidence, explanatory power, and integration in…

  • Is History Science?

    The practice of history embraces induction like other sciences, yet presents distinctive features. Dissent among historians often arises from varied interpretations of historical figures’ intentions, complicated by limited and biased evidence. Historians may overstate actors’ intentions in events like the Fall of the Roman Republic or the Crusades. The “Great Man theory”…

  • Life Choices

    Decisions requiring careful rational assessments involve significant life changes, financial implications, and long-term commitments. Best practices include gathering comprehensive information, analyzing pros and cons, seeking external input, assessing values and priorities, and setting decision deadlines. When considering cutting losses, one should objectively assess the situation, evaluate goals, consider improvement prospects, and trust…

  • Depth or Width of Knowledge?

    The decision between broad and deep knowledge depends on personality traits and goals. Broad knowledge suits the curious and adaptable, while deep knowledge is for the focused and detail-oriented. Modern challenges to being a polymath include vast knowledge, career specialization, time constraints, and societal factors. Different daily habits aid in acquiring deep…

  • Economics – Core Concepts

    The field of economics today is dynamic, embracing technological advancements, interdisciplinary collaboration, and global perspectives. Economists now require proficiency in data analysis, programming, and a broader skill set compared to 50 years ago. They are involved in policy, business applications, and addressing contemporary challenges like inequality and sustainability. Discussing these changes can…

  • What is Metaphysics?

    Metaphysics delves into the fundamental nature of reality, exploring existence, change, consciousness, time, and more. Its significance lies in providing a framework for understanding reality and resolving philosophical questions. While metaphysical depth isn’t strictly essential for practical rationality, it enriches critical thinking and personal development. Perennial debates, like the nature of universals…

  • Metaphysics – Core Concepts

    Metaphysics investigates the fundamental nature of reality, existence, and knowledge. It encompasses essential concepts such as substance, properties, time, and possible worlds. This field has evolved from ancient pre-Socratic inquiries to contemporary explorations of quantum metaphysics, social ontology, and the metaphysics of information. Leading figures include Plato, Aristotle, Descartes, and Kant.

  • Rationality Discussion

    EB and PS engage in a detailed discussion about trust, rationality, and the relationship between belief and evidence. EB starts with an interest in trust, preferring English terminology and questioning reality. PS stresses the need for evidence-based reasoning. When assessing each position, both show strengths and weaknesses. EB’s arguments rely on divine…

  • Belief/Evidence Graphic

    The content discusses rational belief and its alignment with evidence, using a graphic of changing evidence degrees and individual belief degrees. It delves into belief adjustments, threshold models, and dangers of misaligned belief. The quiz and discussion questions cover various aspects of belief, evidence alignment, and decision-making.

  • Economic Comparisons

    The content highlights global and US average incomes, average global incomes per decade since 1850, modern amenities, labor hours for common necessities, and changes in abject poverty rates. It also includes a quiz and discussion questions about global poverty. Global average income is $9,733 annually, while US average income is $77,464 yearly.…

  • Economic Entitlements

    Over the past centuries, humanity has transitioned from primitive economic systems to an age where each generation expects greater economic opportunities than the previous one. This shift brings philosophical, psychological, and sociological implications, raising questions about justice, entitlement, and societal values. Psychology examines the impact of these expectations on individual motivation, self-perception,…

  • What is Economics?

    Economics is the study of how societies allocate resources under scarcity. It encompasses microeconomics (individual and industry behavior) and macroeconomics (economy as a whole). Dominant schools include neoclassical, Keynesian, monetarism, behavioral, Austrian, and institutional economics. A brief timeline of economic thought spans ancient, Middle Ages, mercantilism, classical, marginal revolution, Keynesian, monetarism, Chicago…

  • Philosophy of Mind Basics

    The philosophy of mind delves into consciousness, mental phenomena, and their relation to the body. Major schools of thought include dualism and monism, with subcategories like physicalism. Notable questions include the nature of consciousness, free will, and the mind-body relationship. A multidisciplinary foundation in fields such as neuroscience and psychology enriches advanced…

  • Economic Complexity

    The multi-factorial and interdisciplinary nature of economic analysis leads to tentative, context-dependent conclusions intertwined with human values and behaviors. Economic equilibria are less stable due to shifts in supply and demand, external shocks, adaptive expectations, and time lags. Hyperinflation is less common, while debated topics include income inequality, climate change, and job…

  • What Makes Economics “Dismal”?

    Economics, termed the “dismal science” by Thomas Carlyle, reflected 19th-century critiques but evolved to encompass societal challenges. Modern criticisms on its scientific limitations highlighted issues in isolating variables and historical specificity, with counterpoints emphasizing progress and policy guidance. The discipline’s credibility increased through empirical research, theoretical advancements, and technology, leading to enhanced…

  • Doxastic Voluntarism

    Doxastic Voluntarism explores the control we have over beliefs, divided into direct (choosing beliefs at will) and indirect (influencing beliefs over time). Arguments for it include moral responsibility, while arguments against cite evidentialism and psychological compulsion. Cognitive science generally supports indirect influence, acknowledging belief formation’s complexity. Can we really choose our beliefs?

  • Linguistic Abstraction

    Children develop linguistic maturity by grouping primitive concepts into abstract terms. For example, they progress from “hot, cold, warm” to understanding “temperature.” Einstein’s theory of relativity and quantum mechanics are famous for their abstractness. Plato and Aristotle’s philosophical debates showcased the challenge of abstract communication. You can quiz yourself on these concepts,…

  • The Linearity of Language

    Language and visual displays have unique strengths and weaknesses. While language provides depth, detail, and personal connection, visuals offer instant comprehension and emotional impact. Education is trending towards more visuals to accommodate diverse learning styles. AI has the potential to revolutionize educational content creation, but ethical considerations and limitations must be addressed.…

  • Equivocation on “Wrong”

    In discussions on ethics, the meaning of “wrong” varies across different contexts, potentially leading to equivocation. To prevent this, strategies like defining terms clearly, using specific language, and acknowledging the complexity of ethics are essential. Scenarios where equivocation on “wrong” occurs include political debates, cultural practices, corporate ethics, environmental discussions, and dietary…

  • What is Futurism?

    Futurism involves predicting and understanding potential futures, connecting to philosophy through ethical, epistemological, and ontological questions, and it’s different from forecasting. Universities offering related degrees include the University of Houston and the University of Helsinki. Essential tools for quality futurists include critical thinking, scenario planning, and Bayesian thinking. Top futurists today include…

  • Do Humans have an Essence?

    Existentialism challenges the idea of predetermined human essence, emphasizing individual freedom and responsibility. Notable figures like Sartre, de Beauvoir, and Frankl embodied these principles in their lives. Overcoming shyness aligns with existentialism, emphasizing personal choice and authentic living. The quiz tests understanding of existentialist concepts, from essence to influential figures. Discussion questions…

  • Can Humans Change?

    Existentialists believe essence is not predetermined, and scientific research supports lifelong personality change. Neurological conditions like Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) have inherent characteristics, but individuals can still experience growth and change. Therapy, self-directed change, and nature vs. nurture play significant roles in personality development. Shifting social environments, the ethics of change, tolerating…

  • Competing Ethical Considerations

    The discussion provided covers various ethical considerations and the lack of rigorous hermeneutics in moral systems. It also delves into the influences of emotions on moral decision-making and the role of rationality in ethical reasoning. Additionally, it poses thought-provoking questions about the relationship between moral systems and emotions. Summary: The post covers…

  • Coherent Moral Systems

    The minimal requirements for a coherent moral system claiming objective moral facts include ontological foundation, universalizability, normativity, logical consistency, action-guiding, epistemological accessibility, and normative strength. The objective, ontological foundation can be based on metaphysical realism, theistic foundations, non-natural moral realism, emergent properties, rational constructivism, or other evaluative foundations. Universalizability ensures that moral…

  • Conditions for Culpability

    The content explores moral culpability through various scenarios and conditions. It discusses the impact of determinism on free will and moral responsibility and presents moral assessments for lending a car, misinterpreted friendliness, and embarrassing a boss. A 10-item quiz tests understanding, and 15 discussion questions invite reflection on ethical considerations and moral…

  • Evidences of Moral Facts

    The consideration that human “moral intuitions” may stem from emotions and socially-derived expectations offers a naturalistic explanation for discerning right from wrong without invoking an objective moral realm. Emotions, social interactions, and evolved predispositions seem to play vital roles in shaping moral intuitions, challenging the idea of universally accessible moral truths.

  • Meta-Ethics Focus #2

    The argument questions whether consensus on moral judgments among different groups of moral realists can serve as evidence for the existence of moral facts. It suggests that if the premises grounding moral conclusions are mutually incompatible, mutual agreement cannot be used as evidence. The discussion emphasizes the need for coherent and compatible…

  • Meta-Ethics Focus #1

    The discussion explores moral realism and its relationship to moral culpability, intent, and awareness of moral facts. It addresses the distinction between social norms and objective moral facts and raises questions about moral responsibility, establishing moral facts, and the practical implications of these concepts. The content delves into ethical nuances and challenges,…

  • Meta-Ethics

    Meta-ethics is a branch of ethics focusing on the nature of moral judgments and language. It encompasses moral ontology, epistemology, semantics, psychology, and reasoning. Sources for studying meta-ethics include textbooks, academic journals, online resources, lecture series, podcasts, and philosophy blogs. Rough estimates suggest varied positions among philosophers, emphasizing the importance of understanding…

  • Ethics — Core Concepts

    Ethics Summary: Ethics, a branch of philosophy, explores moral concepts and principles to guide human conduct. Major theories include Virtue Ethics (focused on character), Deontology (based on rules), and Utilitarianism (emphasizing outcomes). Schools of thought, like Feminist Ethics and Moral Nihilism, offer diverse perspectives. New areas of interest, including Digital Ethics and…

  • What are Ethics?

    Ethics, also known as moral philosophy, examines right and wrong behavior and comprises meta-ethics, normative ethics, and applied ethics. Various foundations for moral realms and facts include divine command theory, natural law theory, and consequentialism. Moral skepticism questions objective moral judgments, while moral nihilism denies the existence of moral truths. Ethics is…

Subscribe

Enter your email below to receive updates.


Phil Stilwell

Phil picked up a BA in Philosophy a couple of decades ago. After his MA in Education, he took a 23-year break from reality in Tokyo. He occasionally teaches philosophy and critical thinking courses in university and industry. He is joined here by ChatGPT, GEMINI, CLAUDE, and occasionally Copilot, Perplexity, and Grok, his far more intelligent AI friends. The seven of them discuss and debate a wide variety of philosophical topics I think you’ll enjoy.

Phil curates the content and guides the discussion, primarily through questions. At times there are disagreements, and you may find the banter interesting.

Goals and Observations


Go back

Your message has been sent

Warning
Warning
Warning
Warning.