Project Goals and Observations

#Goals:
1The promotion of philosophical and rational thought.
2The provision of a general foundation to basic philosophical and rational ideas.
3The promotion of AI to assess one’s own ideas and the ideas of others.
4A documentation of the evolution of public large language models.
5To keep Phil curious and occupied.
6To provide a taste of the power of AIs.
7To maintain an loosely organized reference for philosophical notions.
#Observations:
1Gemini tends to push political correctness, often at the expense of clarity and logical rigor. Occasionally, it wrongly attempts to correct true statements. It accepts rebukes graciously.
2All AI platforms employed on the site tend to respond to logically constructed refutations of their positions. To view cases in which they seemed to concede points when provided counter-arguments, search for “Pushback”.
3The AIs are often finicky, often ignoring instructions and dramatically varying the length of their responses. The quizzes, especially, may contain errors in content or formatting.
4You’ll likely find significant overlap of concepts among the posts. However, much effort was made to ensure each post is unique in its own way.
5There is a slight attempt to keep the posts and categories rigorously systematic and balanced as you might find in a textbook. However, the posts are more likely aligned with current public discourse in the relevant fields.
6The AIs have been going a great job at understanding precisely what I am trying to say despite my choice of terms and register. I’ll have to remember to keep my philosophical nomenclature in check for the readers.
#Notes:
1Through April of 2024, Phil used a paid subscription to ChatGPT 4, and the free versions of GEMINI, CLAUDE, and Copilot.
2Readers will encounter both basic articles and highly technical articles. The section at the top of each article should give you a good feel for the level of difficulty.
3Readers should feel free to add comments on the accuracy and coherence of the content.
4There will be an overlap of content across article. This is largely intentional to ensure central themes are emphasized.

Last Modified ▼

Phil Stilwell

Phil picked up a BA in Philosophy a couple of decades ago. He occasionally teaches philosophy and critical thinking courses in university and industry. He is joined here by ChatGPT 4, GEMINI, CLAUDE, and occasionally Copilot, his far more intelligent AI friends. The five of them discuss and debate a wide variety of philosophical topics I think you’ll enjoy.

Phil curates the content and guides the discussion, primarily through questions. At times there are disagreements, and you may find the banter interesting.

— Goals and Observations

Stay informed!

Sign up for new post notices.

Recent Posts

  • John Locke

    John Locke profoundly influenced modern philosophy, challenging prevailing rationalist views and emphasizing knowledge derived from sensory experiences. His concept of the mind as a “tabula rasa” at birth and his political theories significantly impacted political… Read more

  • Dangers: Awe as an Indicator

    The argument presents an insightful perspective on the subjective nature of beauty and the relationship between the observer and the observed. It questions the idea of objective beauty and challenges anthropocentric viewpoints. It also acknowledges… Read more

  • The Power of Statistics

    Statistics play a crucial role in acquiring truth by providing tools for interpreting data, quantifying uncertainty, and making informed decisions. Its power lies in quantifying evidence, pattern recognition, hypothesis testing, decision-making, understanding variability, and effective… Read more

  • Dialoguing with Charles Sanders Peirce

    Charles Sanders Peirce explains his philosophy, covering pragmatism, semiotics, and the scientific method. Pragmatism evaluates ideas by their practical consequences. Semiotics studies signs: icons, indexes, and symbols. The scientific method involves hypothesis, experimentation, and revision.… Read more

  • Baruch Spinoza

    Baruch Spinoza, a 17th-century Dutch philosopher, significantly influenced modern philosophy by challenging traditional dualistic views and championing reason as the path to knowledge. His deterministic view of the universe led to groundbreaking contributions in monism,… Read more

  • Subjectivity Constrained by the Objective

    Subjective experience, influenced by objective reality, emerges from subjective creatures trying to navigate the world. Objective limitations and neural flexibility shape rich subjectivity, displaying various quirks. Cognitive biases, emotional states, and exploratory nature raise potential… Read more

  • Dialoguing with Epicurus

    Epicurus, an influential ancient Greek philosopher, advocated for pleasure as the highest good, tranquility of the mind, and the moderation of desires. While some of his specific ideas have evolved, they continue to shape contemporary… Read more

  • Faith or Evidence?

    This article explores the tension between citing miracles and advocating for faith as a reason to believe in God. It delves into how these concepts are viewed and reconciled within religious epistemology. The passage also… Read more

  • Testing Prayer

    A definitive prayer test would involve a specific, observable miracle, like restoring amputated limbs, occurring within a set timeframe following prayers directed to a specific God. Control groups would be essential to exclude coincidences and… Read more

  • Dialoguing with Socrates

    Socrates’ philosophy has left a lasting impact on critical thinking and ethical exploration. His Socratic Method continues to inspire dialogue in various fields. The notion of ‘the unexamined life is not worth living’ challenges societal… Read more

  • Monetary Goals

    A rational disposition toward money and possessions involves moderation, value-focused decision-making, and long-term planning, prioritizing experiences over material possessions. Historical figures like Diogenes of Sinope and St. Francis of Assisi found happiness through self-sufficiency and… Read more

  • Thomas Aquinas

    Thomas Aquinas, a Dominican friar and theologian of the 13th century, profoundly impacted Western philosophy by integrating Aristotelian philosophy with Christian doctrine. His influence is seen in Scholasticism, natural law theory, and the synthesis of… Read more

  • Culture-Wide Emotional Dispositions

    This article discusses the cultural aspects of emotional expression in Japanese society and its impact on child development. It emphasizes the influence of cultural norms on emotional expression, the effects of emotional suppression in childhood,… Read more

  • Shades of Certainty

    This article critiques the binary notion of belief, arguing that belief and liking exist on a spectrum rather than as fixed categories. It highlights the linguistic and ontological conflicts of oversimplified binary perspectives and emphasizes… Read more

  • Dialoguing with Aristotle

    This article includes lengthy dialogues involving Aristotle discussing his philosophical ideas with various individuals, such as a curious teenager, another philosopher exploring his philosophy, and a critical philosopher confronting him on weaknesses in his philosophy.… Read more

  • Detecting Bad Science

    This article provides insight into spotting bad science, vulnerable science domains, pressures driving improper science, questions to ask when evaluating scientific claims, a quiz on scientific claims, and discussion questions. It covers sensationalized headlines, conflicts… Read more

  • Our View of Humanity

    A distorted view of human nature can severely distort our beliefs about events involving humans. Each of the distorted views presented impacts our perceptions and interactions. Real-life tragedies, such as those involving Ted Kaczynski and… Read more

  • Appreciating our Insignificance 

    Accepting our cosmic insignificance offers advantages such as humility, perspective, unity, innovation, and resilience. Staying grounded amid ideologies promising cosmic importance involves mindfulness, gratitude, rationality, meaningful connections, and limiting exposure to grandiose narratives. Real-life accounts… Read more

  • Charles Sanders Peirce

    Charles Sanders Peirce was a foundational figure in American philosophy, best known as the progenitor of pragmatism. His ideas significantly influenced logic, the philosophy of science, and semiotics. His lasting mark on philosophy includes pragmatism,… Read more

  • Dialoguing with Plato

    Plato’s philosophy revolves around the Theory of Forms, the Allegory of the Cave, the idea of philosopher-kings, and the nature of knowledge and the soul. These concepts continue to provoke debate and inquiry in modern… Read more

  • Edmund Husserl

    Edmund Husserl is the father of phenomenology, challenging prevailing empiricism and positivism. His emphasis on subjective experience and intentionality influenced existentialism and thinkers like Heidegger and Sartre. His 7 key contributions to philosophy include founding… Read more

  • Demarcation for Scientific Laws

    Scientific regularities are consistent patterns observed in nature, while scientific laws are concise statements describing these regularities. Inductive density, based on robust evidence, influences the transition from regularity to law. Conventional acceptance by scientists is… Read more

Recent Posts — Expanded Version
Indicate your interests:

Links to Section Menus