• Hypostatic Illogic

  Believers in Christianity encounter a logical contradiction in the concept of Jesus being 100% human and 100% God. They address this paradox using the doctrine of Hypostatic Union, emphasizing Jesus’ sinlessness, the Kenosis Theory, the role of the Holy Spirit, the mystery of faith, and distinct roles of natures. This presents a…

• Profiling

  Law enforcement visual and digital profiling can enhance crime detection and resource optimization, but risks violating privacy rights and undermining public trust. The tension between inductive assessments and presumed innocence raises ethical and legal challenges. Profiling’s value ranges from low (routine traffic stops) to high (cybersecurity threat assessment), with potential benefits and…

• Charting Duns Scotus

  John Duns Scotus sparked tension with his contemporaries through his univocity of being, formal distinction, haecceity, and Immaculate Conception. His ideas clashed with Thomas Aquinas, Bonaventure, and Albertus Magnus, igniting debates on metaphysics and theology. How do these philosophical clashes reflect the dynamic nature of medieval thought and impact contemporary discourse?

• Dialoguing with Dewey

  This article explores John Dewey through fictional dialogues and lists his five most influential philosophical notions and their current acceptance among philosophers. Dewey’s pragmatism emphasizes the practical consequences and applications of ideas, focusing on the interplay between thought and action. This notion remains widely accepted, particularly in American philosophy and education. Instrumentalism,…

• Dialoguing with William James

  In this article, William James engages in a dialogue with a curious teenager to explain his philosophical views. He begins by discussing pragmatism, a central aspect of his philosophy, which evaluates the truth of beliefs and theories based on their practical consequences and usefulness. James emphasizes that truth is dynamic and evolves…

• Duns Scotus

  Duns Scotus, a medieval philosopher and theologian, significantly impacted Western philosophy through his innovative concepts and rigorous approach. His contributions include defining haecceity, asserting the univocity of being, proposing formal distinction, advocating voluntarism, and developing a precise scholastic methodology. Scotus’ influence extends to metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, theology, and modern philosophical traditions.

• Dangers: Siloed Ideologies

  Siloed ideologies exhibit common traits like one-way conversations, cutting ties with “heretics,” scripted responses, staged interactions with non-believers, intrusive interventions, and a focus on what to think. The notion of an evil force like Satan and a hostile disposition towards honest doubt can entrap minds within these false ideologies by deflecting responsibility,…

• John Dewey

  John Dewey, a pragmatic philosopher, greatly influenced philosophy through his emphasis on experience, practicality, and the consequences of ideas. His notable contributions include shaping pragmatism, promoting experiential learning, advocating for democracy in education, and developing a theory of inquiry. Dewey’s interdisciplinary philosophy left a lasting impact on education, psychology, ethics, political theory,…

• Charting William James

  William James, a pivotal figure in philosophy, faced intellectual tension with philosophers misaligned with his views on pragmatism, radical empiricism, the will to believe, stream of consciousness, pluralism, psychology and religion, and functionalism in psychology. Notable opponents included Immanuel Kant, G.W.F. Hegel, Bertrand Russell, W.K. Clifford, and others. Their conflicts spanned truth,…

• Dialoguing with Marx

  Karl Marx’s philosophy, encompassing historical materialism, class struggle, alienation, commodity fetishism, and the dictatorship of the proletariat, has left a lasting impact on modern thought. While some notions are widely accepted, such as historical materialism and class struggle, others, like the dictatorship of the proletariat, have faced criticism. Discussion questions include exploring…

• Torturing Babies

  This article explores Tom’s perspective on the morality of torturing babies, where he finds the act emotionally abhorrent but not immoral due to a lack of legitimate moral grounding. Tom distinguishes between emotional reactions and moral judgments, suggesting that while his disgust is genuine, it does not equate to a moral wrong.…

• Harris’ Notion of Morality

  The first essay by Sam Harris claims that science can determine human values based on the study of well-being, while the second essay from a moral anti-realist perspective critiques the reification of morality and the use of emotionally charged language. The syllogistic renderings capture the primary logical structures of both essays, and…

• Circularity in Moral Realism

  This post explores the circularity in defining moral concepts within moral realism. Seven moral philosophers’ quotes are analyzed, highlighting the logical flaws in their definitions. Each quote is accompanied by a reductio syllogism demonstrating circularity. Fourteen discussion questions further delve into the implications and challenges of circular reasoning in moral philosophy.

• Fictional Meta-Ethics Debate

  Stilwell and Yudkowsky engage in a dialogue on meta-ethics, debating the nature of moral intuitions. Stilwell asserts that moral intuitions are emotional and suggests using terms like “emotions” or “values.” They further discuss normative force, moral anti-realism, and replacing “moral landscape” with “landscape of socially acceptable behaviors.” The feasibility of challenging the…

• Factual Disagreements vs Semantic Misunderstandings

  When what appears to be a factual disagreement is actually a semantic misunderstanding, confusion can arise. The precise definitions of terms are essential to avoid such misunderstandings. It fosters clear communication, avoids ambiguity, and promotes deeper understanding and persuasive power in discussions, especially in interdisciplinary projects and academic discourse. JETPACK_AI_ERROR

• Charting Foucault

  Michel Foucault, a prominent philosopher, and his misaligned counterparts engage in profound intellectual clashes. Their divergent views on knowledge, power, punishment, and sexuality lead to rich and contentious debates. These tensions reflect deeper philosophical divides and the evolving nature of philosophical inquiry, pushing the boundaries of understanding and shaping contemporary philosophy.

• William James

  William James, an influential American philosopher and psychologist, made significant contributions to philosophy. His development of pragmatism and radical empiricism shifted philosophical inquiry from abstract theorization to practical outcomes and human experiences. James’ work influenced a broad range of disciplines, including psychology and literature, through concepts like “the stream of consciousness” and…

• Dialoguing with Foucault

  Foucault’s philosophy has had a profound influence on critical theory, social sciences, and political philosophy. His concepts of power/knowledge, disciplinary power, biopolitics, archaeology of knowledge, and genealogy are widely accepted and reshaped understandings of how power operates in society. Despite critiques and debates, his ideas continue to influence and inspire scholarly work.

• Leaving Room for Doubt

  This article discusses the importance of maintaining epistemic humility and avoiding full certainty, highlighting the benefits of an open-minded approach and the dangers of ideologies exploiting the human drive for certainty. It features notable quotes, explanations of the importance of non-dogmatic openness, and discussion questions. It emphasizes the significance of embracing uncertainty…

• Charting Marx

  Karl Marx’s groundbreaking theories on historical materialism, alienation, class struggle, and surplus value have sparked vigorous debate among philosophers like Max Weber, Jean-Paul Sartre, and Karl Popper. This clash of ideologies continues to shape contemporary thought, exploring fundamental questions of social order, freedom, and human flourishing. How do Marx’s ideas resonate with…

• Knowledge & Cognition Asymmetry

  As knowledge complexity and abstraction grow, the human mind’s ability to keep pace is challenged. Strategies such as leveraging technology, enhancing education, and fostering interdisciplinary collaboration can mitigate this asymmetry. Neuronal/silicon interfaces offer promising solutions, including advanced information processing, memory enhancement, and personalized knowledge representation. These developments raise ethical and integration challenges…

• Charting Quine

  Willard Van Orman Quine’s groundbreaking philosophical ideas, such as his rejection of the analytic-synthetic distinction and advocacy for ontological relativity, provoked intense debates with contemporaries like Rudolf Carnap, A.J. Ayer, and C.I. Lewis. The tension arose due to conflicting views on pivotal concepts like meaning, truth, and the nature of knowledge. Quine’s…

• Dangers: Promissory Treasures

  Many ideologies promise rewards in an afterlife, shaping human behavior through various mechanisms. These include alleviating existential fear, establishing moral frameworks, deferring gratification, fostering social cohesion, exercising authority, and providing psychological comfort. When responding to an unsubstantiated claim about the afterlife, it’s crucial to acknowledge the claim, request evidence, present alternative perspectives,…

• Michel Foucault

  Michel Foucault profoundly impacted philosophy by challenging traditional notions of power, knowledge, and social institutions. His concepts of power-knowledge, discourse analysis, and genealogical method have significantly influenced post-structuralism, critical theory, feminist theory, and post-colonial theory. Foucault’s work has also shaped disciplines such as sociology, cultural studies, history, and political science, providing critical…

• Can Words Constitute Violence?

  This article discusses the redefinition of violence to include words, the potential consequences of this shift, and the impact on society and free speech. It explores the dangers of equating words with violence and the implications for conflict resolution and civil discourse. The passage raises ethical concerns and examines the psychological and…

• Do Rationalists Skew Neurodivergent?

  This article discusses the correlation between scientific and rational pursuits and neurodivergent traits and includes historical observations, contemporary research, societal and educational implications, and the correlation between childhood trauma/deprivation and neurodiversity. It also explores neurodivergent individuals’ reported general happiness levels and deficiencies in aspects of rationality commonly exhibited by them. The section…

• Neurotypical & Neurodivergent Minds

  This article provides a critical analysis of a chart comparing neurotypical and neurodivergent traits, along with alternative visual and descriptive representations. It explores the dimensions of difference between neurotypical and neurodivergent minds, emphasizing the spectrum nature of neurodiversity. Additionally, it includes discussion questions relevant to neurodiversity, cognitive differences, and societal implications.

• The Motive Fallacy

  The deflection tactic in public discourse involves shifting the focus from the original topic or argument to untestable and unfalsifiable accusations of ignoble motivations. Use the motive fallacy to attack the person presenting the argument, rather than the argument itself. There are three categories of discussion questions: those on deflection tactics and…

• Karl Marx

  Karl Marx, a revolutionary 19th-century philosopher, economist, and political theorist, left an indelible mark on philosophy. He challenged prevailing ideologies with his materialist perspective and dialectical historical materialism. The causes behind his acclaim include the socio-economic upheaval of the Industrial Revolution, his partnership with Friedrich Engels, and his rigorous academic background. Marx’s…

• Evolution & Rationality

  The article provides a comprehensive rebuttal to the arguments presented by Alvin Plantinga, C.S. Lewis, Thomas Nagel, and John Gray against the compatibility of evolution and rationality. It critically examines each philosopher’s premise and conclusion, offering logical counterarguments and highlighting the flaws in their reasoning. Plantinga’s argument is challenged by noting that…

• Dialoguing with Quine

  This article delves into W.V.O. Quine’s significant philosophical contributions, focusing on five influential notions: the rejection of the analytic-synthetic distinction, ontological relativity, the indeterminacy of translation, holism (web of belief), and naturalized epistemology. Quine’s challenge to the analytic-synthetic distinction argues against a clear boundary between logical truths and empirical facts, proposing that…

• Charting Merleau-Ponty

  Maurice Merleau-Ponty, a leading 20th-century philosopher, challenged established traditions with his innovative views on perception, embodiment, and political philosophy. His tensions with Descartes, Kant, Fodor, and others underscored core disagreements on the body’s role in cognition, the intertwining of subject and object, and the primacy of perception. These debates continue to influence…

• Maintaining Scientific Credibility

  Public policy-makers often face a dilemma: whether to speak the scientific truth and risk public panic, or to protect their reputation by distorting facts. This raises ethical and practical considerations, with examples including the Cuban Missile Crisis and the Y2K Bug. Guidelines advise transparency, collaboration, and public trust maintenance. An analogy compares…

• Non-Scientific Ways of Knowing

  The article explores whether there can be ways of knowing that do not require the scientific method yet remain coherent, rigorous, and testable. It examines coherence, defined as logical consistency within knowledge systems, rigor, involving thoroughness and precision, and testability, the ability to verify claims through empirical observation or experimentation. The scientific…

• Dialoguing with Berkeley

  This article explores the key philosophical notions of George Berkeley, focusing on his immaterialism, the principle “to be is to be perceived,” the role of God in sustaining reality, his critique of abstract ideas, and phenomenalism. Berkeley’s immaterialism argues that physical objects exist only as perceptions in the mind, rejecting the notion…

• Willard Van Orman Quine

  Willard Van Orman Quine, a 20th-century American philosopher, profoundly impacted philosophy by challenging the analytic-synthetic distinction and advocating for naturalized epistemology. His 7 greatest contributions include rejecting the analytic-synthetic distinction, indeterminacy of translation, ontological relativity, naturalized epistemology, holism, theory-ladenness of observation, and confirmation holism. Quine’s influence extends to analytic philosophy, philosophy of…

• AI & the Future of Work

  Avital Balwit, Chief of Staff to the CEO at Anthropic, examines the future of work in the AI age, discussing the potential for widespread unemployment due to AI advancements. Balwit’s arguments highlight the psychological and societal impacts of AI-induced work changes. While addressing the positive aspects, she emphasizes the need for a…

• Wisdom Dynamics

  Societal wisdom can be enhanced through cultural transmission, increased longevity, respect for older individuals, and additional sources such as diverse cultural exchange, scientific advancements, and ethical reflection. It is challenging to create robust metrics for societal wisdom due to the evolving nature of standards and the influence of power and ideology. Discussion…

• The Growing Disinclination for War

  Steven Pinker, a cognitive scientist, contends that humanity experiences fewer deadly wars today than in the past. Substantiating his argument, he cites historical data showing a decline in war frequency and lethality, attributed to economic, political, social, cultural, and technological influences. Pinker’s perspective is supported by various studies and reports, highlighting a…

• Dangers: Explanatory Depth Illusions

  Many ideologies offer the illusion of depth, appealing to individuals with a low tolerance for uncertainty and a high tolerance for lack of evidence. They rely on emotional appeals, promissory claims, and resistance to criticism. These traits appeal to diverse personalities through emotional resonance, adaptability, and cognitive biases. Warning signs include simplistic…

• Dialoguing with Merleau-Ponty

  The dialogue in this article highlights that perception is an active engagement with the world, not just passive data reception. Merleau-Ponty discusses the primacy of perception, asserting that our primary engagement with the world is through perception, forming the foundation for all higher understanding. He also explains that understanding reality involves intersubjectivity,…

• Charting Berkeley

  George Berkeley, an 18th-century Irish philosopher and bishop, espoused radical idealism and immaterialism, challenging prevailing materialism and empiricism. His views clashed with contemporary thinkers like Hobbes, Locke, Hume, Russell, and Kant. Berkeley’s tension with these adversaries illuminates profound divergences in understanding reality, perception, and knowledge. These philosophical debates offer valuable insights into…

• What is Etiology?

  Etiology, derived from the Greek “aitia” (cause) and “logos” (study), encompasses the study of causation’s philosophical and practical implications. It explores the causal mechanisms of events, diverging into historical, contemporary philosophy with influential figures such as Aristotle, challenges such as the problem of induction, and practical applications in fields like medicine, public…

• Maurice Merleau-Ponty

  Maurice Merleau-Ponty, a leading 20th-century French philosopher, has profoundly impacted existential and phenomenological philosophy. His emphasis on the embodied nature of human experience and challenging Cartesian dualism has influenced diverse fields, including cognitive science, existentialism, and aesthetics. Merleau-Ponty’s work continues to inspire contemporary philosophers and has influenced schools of thought and academic…

• The Illusion of Knowledge

  The content of this article explores the detrimental impact of the illusion of knowledge compared to recognized ignorance. Historical cases and hallmarks of false knowledge mentality are examined, highlighting the importance of humility and continuous learning. Discussion questions encourage reflection on psychological factors, educational strategies, and navigating the information age.

• George Berkeley

  George Berkeley, an 18th-century Irish philosopher, had a profound influence on philosophy, challenging materialism and empiricism with his idealism. His concept of “esse est percipi” and critiques of abstract ideas and material substance influenced later philosophers like David Hume and Immanuel Kant. Berkeley’s work continues to inspire debates in metaphysics, epistemology, and…

• Sara Walker on Life’s Emergence

  This podcast interview discusses complex topics such as computation, cellular automata, and the nature of reality, featuring a detailed assessment of their factual accuracy, logical coherence, and testability. Sara Imari Walker’s profile is provided, as well as a deep dive into the primary arguments in the transcript, including syllogisms and causal chains.…

• Metrics for Cultural Comparisons

  This article discusses the evaluation of human well-being in different cultures based on various metrics and factors. It covers the impact of institutional and cultural sources on societal well-being and delves into the influence of chance and deliberate policies. The material also emphasizes social virtues correlated with successful cultures and provides discussion…

• Red, Blue, & Grey Tribes

  The red, blue, and grey tribes in US society represent distinct cultural and political groupings. The red tribe aligns with the Republican party and emphasizes traditional values and limited government intervention. The blue tribe aligns with the Democratic party and prioritizes progressive values and inclusivity. The grey tribe, consisting of independents, emphasizes…

• Vague Tags of Identification

  The essay “Why I don’t call myself an ‘Atheist’” discusses the propensity of humans to adopt self-identifying tags that lack rigorous denotation, such as the label “atheist.” It highlights the imprecision and lack of nuance in identity labels and the potential consequences of insisting on one’s own denotation.

• Assembly Theory

  Assembly theory is a framework aiming to understand the complexity and origins of life, focusing on the formation and organization of complex structures from simpler components. Key concepts include complexity measurement, pathways, and assembly index. Implications span astrobiology, synthetic biology, and evolutionary biology. Recent advances include refinement of assembly index calculations and…

• AIs in Politics

  AI Steve, a candidate for the UK’s general election, represented by businessman Steve Endacott, aims to humanize politics by engaging with constituents and proposing policies. The potential strengths of AIs in political office include continuous engagement, data-driven decision making, and impartiality, while weaknesses encompass lack of human empathy and ethical judgments. AIs…

• Life vs Non-Life

  The demarcation between biological life and non-life is ambiguous, challenged by entities like viruses and prions that exhibit characteristics of both. The practical, theoretical, and philosophical implications of a clear distinction are substantial, influencing fields like medical research and ethical considerations. This blurriness drives scientific exploration and necessitates a nuanced approach to…

• Self-Reported AI Capabilities: 06/24

  This table presents a clear overview of AI capabilities for web-based public AI bots. It categorizes these capabilities into “Recently Acquired,” “Beta Stage,” and “1-Year Away” for various domains like Natural Language Understanding, Natural Language Generation, Conversational AI, Information Retrieval, Sentiment Analysis, Text Summarization, Translation and Language Support, Personalized Recommendations, Contextual Awareness,…

• “Unpalatable” Religions

  The article discusses a religious leader’s arguments for the authenticity and divine origin of his religion based on its challenging and counterintuitive nature. The leader highlights several points: the religion’s illogical core concept, austere ethics, requirement for humility and cleansing, and counterintuitive principles like servant leadership. He argues that these features contradict…

• Case #5 – Grade Inflation

  This article discusses the probable causes of grade inflation in US universities, a 5-year plan to roll back grade inflation, potential perverse incentives in the proposed plan, and provides discussion questions. The causes of grade inflation include student culture, pedagogical culture, institutional culture, shifting standards, and more. The 5-year plan focuses on…

• A History of Golden Rules

  The concept of treating others as you wish to be treated has appeared in various forms across cultures and religions throughout history. Major religions, including ancient Egyptian, Indian, Greek, Chinese, Persian, Jewish, Christian, Islamic, and Buddhist traditions, have all expressed variations of this principle. Factors contributing to its emergence in civilizations include…

• Elitzur on Consciousness

  This article is based on a talk by Avshalom Elitzur, and delves into the mystery of consciousness, exploring the challenges in understanding subjective experiences, known as qualia. It presents formal arguments, weaknesses, and a logical essay encapsulating the speaker’s position. The assessment points to the limitations of current scientific methods in explaining…

• Confidentiality of LLM Weights

  Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 are powered by deep neural networks whose performance and capabilities are largely determined by their weights—the parameters learned during the training process. The weights are considered trade secrets and possibly related to national security for several key reasons. They represent substantial intellectual property, competitive advantages, and…

• Charting Epictetus

  Epictetus’ philosophical tenets, including the dichotomy of control and practical ethics, are fiercely debated by philosophers like Nietzsche, Sartre, and Foucault. These conflicts illuminate broader philosophical inquiries into the nature of human freedom and the practicality of ethical principles. Discussion questions offer a framework for exploring these complex concepts in depth.

• IQ & Evolution

  The evolution of human intelligence stemmed from diverse factors such as environmental challenges, social complexity, tool use, nutritional shifts, sexual selection, and genetic mutations. These dynamics propelled cognitive development, while contrasting factors, like significant energy demands and potential social exploitation, acted as barriers. Future higher intellect may arise from environmental, social, technological,…

• Dialoguing with Epictetus

  The article presents a dialogue between Epictetus, a renowned Stoic philosopher, and a curious teenager eager to understand Stoicism. The teenager begins by asking Epictetus to define virtue, which Epictetus explains as the highest good, encompassing wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance. The dialogue explores the challenge of always being virtuous, with Epictetus…

• Assisted Suicide

  Assisted suicide sparks intense moral debate. Advocates tout personal autonomy and compassion, while opponents emphasize sanctity of life and potential abuse. Ethical theories like utilitarianism, deontology, and virtue ethics weigh in, showcasing deep divergence in moral evaluation. This stark contrast suggests intrinsic incommensurability among ethical theories, undermining claims of objective morality based…

• Charting Derrida

  Jacques Derrida’s work, particularly deconstruction, created a philosophical tug-of-war with critics like Michel Foucault and Jürgen Habermas. The concept of différance intensified this tension, drawing critiques from figures like Noam Chomsky and Hilary Putnam. Logocentrism, phonocentrism, and the metaphysics of presence also sparked divergent views. This dynamic interaction enriches philosophical discourse.

• The 15-Hour Workweek

  John Maynard Keynes predicted a 15-hour workweek by 2030, but this seems unlikely due to economic growth, income inequality, cultural factors, economic policies, technological impact, economic structure, and personal choice. The inherent human disposition to work longer hours despite economic freedom is influenced by psychological, social, and environmental factors. Sexual selection may…

• AI Situational Awareness Paper

  This report, “Situational Awareness: The Decade Ahead,” authored by Leopold Aschenbrenner, offers an extensive analysis of the potential impacts of AGI and superintelligence. The report’s strengths lie in its well-founded credences, but improvements are needed in providing a more balanced perspective, deeper explanations, illustrative examples, and detailed discussion of proactive measures and…

• Dialoguing with Heidegger

  The article presents a dialogue between Martin Heidegger and a teenager curious about his philosophical concepts, specifically focusing on Being and Dasein. Heidegger explains that Being addresses the fundamental question of existence, transcending individual beings to consider the essence of existence itself. Dasein, meaning “being there,” refers to human beings who uniquely…

• The Double Descent Phenomenon

  The “double descent” phenomenon challenges traditional beliefs about overfitting in AI models, leading to a more nuanced understanding of model complexity and performance. Overparameterization, where models have more parameters than necessary, plays a critical role in this phenomenon by defying traditional biases against highly complex models. Analogies like learning to play an…

• Overfitting in Scientific Models

  Overfitting occurs when a model becomes excessively tailored to the specific training data, capturing noise and leading to poor performance on new data. This can happen in scientific modeling, machine learning, and other domains, impacting the model’s accuracy and reliability. Strategies to mitigate overfitting include cross-validation, regularization, and data augmentation. However, overfitting…

• AI Response to Pushback

  This article presents observations of AI reactions to pushback, strategies for maintaining balance in AI behavior, the potential benefits of misalignment between human and AI opinions, and discussion questions regarding AI behavior and interaction. It explores instances of AI illogic, defense of illogical ideas, causal assumptions, and techniques for balancing dogmatism and…

Go to Menu Structure