What would count against an ideology?

The five original prompts and ten separate responses are restored. Editorial revisions distinguish internal contradiction from empirical failure, retain the curator’s challenge to untested religious promises, and make the quizzes agree with the distinctions being taught.

Original WordPress conversation, February 14, 2024

Highlights · edited summary

  • A coherent set of beliefs can still be false.
  • Respect for believers does not exempt factual promises from scrutiny.
  • Specify outcomes and conditions before testing, and distinguish contradictions from other failures.

Read This First

If this page feels abrupt, start here

These links provide the wider frame, earlier distinction, or branch map that makes the current page easier to enter.

  1. Philosophical Inquiry Branch Guide

    Start with map

    If this page feels abrupt, start with the Philosophical Inquiry branch guide so the wider map is visible before the close reading begins.

Read This Next

If the page clicked, continue here

These are not just nearby pages. They are the strongest next moves if you want the pressure of this page to keep unfolding.

  1. The Mindset of the Honest Seeker

    Nearby turn

    The Mindset of the Honest Seeker keeps the same branch pressure in view but turns it from a different angle.

  2. Do I need a “worldview”?

    Nearby turn

    Do I need a “worldview”? keeps the same branch pressure in view but turns it from a different angle.

  3. What is Truth?

    Nearby turn

    What is Truth? keeps the same branch pressure in view but turns it from a different angle.

Prompt 1: What are some ways to test the coherency and veracity of the claims of ideologies?

Testing consistency, truth and consequences

ChatGPT response · editorial edition

Separate three questions: can the claims all be true together, are they supported by evidence, and are their consequences acceptable? These tests interact, but success on one does not guarantee success on the others. A coherent fiction is still a fiction; an attractive goal does not establish that a policy will achieve it.

  1. Define the Ideology Clearly: Begin by articulating the core claims, principles, and goals of the ideology in question. This involves identifying the foundational beliefs and propositions that the ideology asserts as true.
  2. Assess Internal Coherence:
  • Logical Consistency: Evaluate the ideology’s claims for logical consistency. Check for contradictions within its own assertions. An ideology should not hold mutually exclusive beliefs as simultaneously true.
  • Conceptual Clarity: Analyze the ideology for clear definitions and concepts. Ambiguity in fundamental concepts can undermine the ideology’s coherence.
  1. Compare with Empirical Evidence:
  • Historical Analysis: Examine historical instances where the ideology has been applied or its principles have been enacted. Assess the outcomes against the ideology’s predictions or promises.
  • Empirical Data: Use relevant data and research findings to test the empirical claims of the ideology. This could involve statistical analysis, case studies, or comparative research.
  1. Evaluate the Ideology’s Logical Structure:
  • Argumentative Strength: Analyze the strength of the arguments that the ideology uses to support its claims. This includes examining the premises for truthfulness and the validity of the logical deductions.
  • Counterarguments: Examine the strongest objections and the actual replies. Repeating a claim, insulating it from every possible objection or retaining loyal supporters is not evidence that criticism has been answered.
  1. Cross-Comparison:
  • Similar Ideologies: Compare the ideology with others that share similar goals or premises. Identifying where they converge and diverge can provide insights into their respective coherency and veracity.
  • Contrasting Ideologies: Examine how the ideology stands in contrast to opposing ideologies. This comparison can help highlight strengths, weaknesses, and the distinctiveness of its claims.
  1. Practical Implications:
  • Feasibility: Assess the practicality of implementing the ideology’s principles in real-world scenarios. Consider both current and historical contexts.
  • Consequences: Evaluate the potential and actual consequences of adopting the ideology. This includes both intended outcomes and unintended side effects.
  1. Philosophical Underpinnings:
  • Ethical Foundations: Identify the values being defended and the reasons offered for them. Agreement with a popular moral standard is not by itself proof, and disagreement is not automatically incoherence.
  • Epistemological Assumptions: Examine the ideology’s assumptions about knowledge, truth, and reality. Assess whether these assumptions are justified.
  1. Ongoing Critique and Revision:
  • Adaptability: Distinguish revisions prompted by evidence from changes made only to evade a failed test. State what changed, why, and what the revised claim now predicts. Some core principles may themselves need revision.
  • Intellectual Discourse: Engage with the academic and intellectual discourse surrounding the ideology. Scholarly critique and debate can provide deep insights into the ideology’s strengths and weaknesses.

This structured approach allows for a comprehensive and nuanced evaluation of ideologies, ensuring that the assessment is thorough, balanced, and informed by a wide range of perspectives and evidence.

Gemini response · editorial edition

Evaluating ideologies critically involves examining both their internal consistency (coherency) and the truthfulness of their claims (veracity). Here are some approaches you can use:

Testing Coherency:

  • Internal consistency: Check for contradictions within the ideology’s central tenets and arguments. Do different aspects of the ideology conflict with each other, or create logical loopholes?
  • Clarity and definition: Examine whether key terms and concepts are clearly defined and consistently used throughout the ideology. Ambiguity can mask logical inconsistencies.
  • Explanatory power: Check whether the account explains evidence rather than selecting only congenial facts. This concerns explanatory adequacy and truth, not merely internal consistency.
  • Predictive ability: Record predictions in advance and assess failures as well as successes. Failure can reveal false assumptions or poor application even when an argument is logically consistent.

Testing Veracity:

  • Evidence and data: Scrutinize the evidence used to support the ideology’s claims. Is it credible, unbiased, and verifiable? Look for independent corroboration and consider alternative interpretations.
  • Logical fallacies: Be aware of and identify common logical fallacies used to manipulate or mislead, such as appeals to emotion, strawman arguments, or false dichotomies.
  • Source analysis: Investigate relevant expertise, methods and incentives. A biased advocate can make a true claim; an admirable origin does not make a doctrine true. Use this information to guide scrutiny rather than substitute for it.
  • Alternative explanations: Explore whether other ideologies or theories can explain the same phenomena with equal or greater evidence and explanatory power.
  • Real-world impact: Evaluate the real-world consequences of the ideology’s implementation. Are the outcomes positive, negative, or neutral? Do they align with the predicted benefits or create unforeseen problems?

Additional Points:

  • Critical thinking: Remember, no ideology is perfect. Approach all ideologies with a critical eye, questioning assumptions, evidence, and reasoning.
  • Context matters: Consider the social, political, and economic context in which an ideology arises and is applied. Different contexts might require different approaches and solutions.
  • Multiple perspectives: Expose yourself to diverse viewpoints and engage in respectful dialogue with those who hold different beliefs. Understanding different perspectives can help you identify blind spots and refine your own thinking.

By applying these approaches to any ideology, you can develop a well-informed and nuanced understanding of its strengths and weaknesses, allowing you to engage in meaningful discussions and decision-making.

Prompt 2: Many religions suggest there are promises that their religion makes to its followers but then claim it is wrong for us to statistically test those claims. Does this warrant the suspicion that the claimed promises are not actually fulfilled? How might we encourage a rigorous test of those promises?

Testing religious promises fairly and rigorously

ChatGPT response · editorial edition

Yes: when a religion advertises an observable benefit but rules out a fair test of that very benefit, skepticism is warranted. Refusal does not prove that the promise fails or establish the claimant’s motive; it leaves the evidential burden unmet. First specify the promise, since a claim about a measurable outcome needs a different assessment from an unrestricted metaphysical claim.

  1. Understanding the Nature of Religious Claims:
  • Religious claims often involve metaphysical assertions that are not easily measurable or testable in the same way as physical phenomena. Many of these claims are based on faith, personal transformation, and subjective experiences, which are inherently difficult to quantify.
  • It’s important to distinguish between claims that can be empirically tested (e.g., the impact of religious practices on health or well-being) and those that are purely metaphysical (e.g., the existence of an afterlife).
  1. Ethical and Epistemological Considerations:
  • Testing people requires consent, appropriate privacy and safeguards against harm. Respecting their right to believe does not require exempting public factual claims from criticism or protecting those claims against unfavorable results.
  • There is also an epistemological aspect regarding the limits of scientific inquiry and the recognition that not all aspects of human experience are fully accessible or explicable through empirical means.
  1. Approaches to Testing Claims Within a Religious Context:
  • Identify Testable Claims: Write down the promised outcome, eligible participants, conditions, time frame and what would count as failure before collecting results. If the promise concerns healing, improvement in reported calm would test a different claim; do not quietly substitute a more convenient outcome.
  • Interdisciplinary Research: Invite proponents to confirm that the test represents their claim, and independent researchers to scrutinize the design. Agree on fair comparisons and analysis beforehand so neither side can redefine success after seeing the result.
  • Longitudinal Studies: Following people over time can reveal patterns, but association alone does not establish a religious cause. Consider prior differences, selection, changes in participation and other explanations; a suitable comparison group matters.
  1. Fostering a Dialogue Between Science and Religion:
  • Promote a culture of dialogue where religious and scientific communities can engage in conversations about the nature of truth, belief, and evidence. This involves mutual respect for the methods and limitations of both religious belief and scientific inquiry.
  • Encourage religious groups to share and discuss the outcomes and benefits of their practices in a way that can be appreciated by both religious and non-religious individuals, potentially opening avenues for empirical investigation.
  1. Ethical and Respectful Inquiry:
  • Respectful inquiry may legitimately test whether a claim is false. Protect participants and describe limitations honestly while allowing results to support, weaken or leave the promise unresolved. Respect concerns how the test is conducted, not a promise to spare the doctrine from refutation.

A fair test neither presumes religious promises false nor grants them immunity. Agree on the claim and criteria, make the procedure open to criticism, and report failures as readily as successes. A claimant who rejects every possible unfavorable result has withdrawn the promise from empirical testing, not supplied evidence for it.

Gemini response · editorial edition

Refusal to test an advertised observable promise can reasonably lower confidence, especially if success stories are accepted as evidence while unfavorable comparisons are forbidden. It is not proof of nonfulfillment. The challenge is to design a test of the actual promise rather than replace it with a different question:

Challenges in Testing Religious Claims:

  • Definition of fulfillment: Religious promises often deal with subjective experiences, internal states, or future events. Defining precise, measurable criteria for what constitutes fulfillment can be highly subjective and vary between individuals and communities.
  • Methodology: Designing studies that isolate the impact of religious practices from other contributing factors like genetics, culture, and individual choices is methodologically challenging.
  • Faith and evidence: A tradition may value trust or personal experience. That preference does not establish the truth of a public factual promise. If favorable observations are cited, ask why comparable unfavorable observations would not count.
  • Ethical considerations: Manipulating individuals’ religious beliefs for research purposes raises ethical concerns, and obtaining informed consent can be complex.

Potential Approaches and Suspicion:

  • Qualitative Research: Interviews can clarify what adherents mean by fulfillment and reveal overlooked outcomes. They do not by themselves establish how often a benefit occurs or what causes it.
  • Case Studies: Carefully documented cases can generate hypotheses and sometimes challenge a universal claim. Selected successes cannot establish a general rate of fulfillment; record failures and the selection process too.
  • Openness to Dialogue: Encouraging open and respectful dialogue between religious communities and researchers can build trust and facilitate collaboration on potential research approaches that address concerns from both sides.
  • Keeping the Focus: Study well-being or social cohesion when those are the promised benefits. If the advertised promise concerns something else, label such work as a separate inquiry rather than a successful test of the original claim.

Suspicion and Oversimplification:

Reluctance can reflect distrust, practical barriers or disagreement over the claim, so motives should not be guessed. Still, none of those possibilities supplies the missing evidence. Ask which fair procedure the claimant would accept and which outcome would reduce their confidence.

Conclusion:

A rigorous test needs a specified claim, agreed outcomes, appropriate comparisons and a plan for reporting all results. Dialogue can make the test fairer; it must not make the result predetermined or convert methodological difficulty into immunity from scrutiny.

Prompt 3: List some of the most commonly found internal incoherencies that are commonly found within ideologies?

Contradictions and other defects in reasoning

ChatGPT response · editorial edition

A strict internal contradiction commits an ideology to claims that cannot both hold in the same sense under the same conditions. Several related defects are listed below, but failed predictions, bad arguments and practical tradeoffs are not all contradictions. These are diagnostic categories, not an empirical ranking of prevalence:

  1. Contradictory Objectives: An ideology may promote goals that are mutually exclusive or in conflict with each other, making it impossible to achieve them simultaneously. For example, an ideology might advocate for absolute freedom of speech while also endorsing censorship of certain viewpoints deemed harmful, creating a conflict between the principles of freedom and protection.
  2. Inconsistent Application of Principles: An ideology may demand equal treatment under a stated rule while exempting favored members without a relevant distinction. Failure to achieve an ideal is not automatically a contradictory belief; ask whether the exception is endorsed, justified or acknowledged as a failure.
  3. Logical Fallacies in Argumentation: A straw man or unsupported inference weakens the offered justification, but does not necessarily make the conclusion false or the doctrine internally contradictory. Relevant expert evidence and supported causal chains are not fallacious merely because authority or consequences are mentioned.
  4. Utopianism vs. Pragmatism: Unrealistic assumptions can make a plan infeasible. This becomes an internal contradiction only if the ideology also accepts constraints that rule out its promised result; otherwise it may be an empirical error or an unresolved aspiration.
  5. Historical Revisionism: Changing an account in light of better evidence is legitimate. Selectively denying contrary evidence to protect an ideology is the defect at issue. It may produce factual error without an explicit internal contradiction.
  6. Ethical Inconsistencies: Endorsing an exception to an allegedly exceptionless rule is contradictory. Advocating peace while allowing defensive force may instead involve a stated priority or distinction; evaluate that rationale before declaring inconsistency.
  7. Theoretical vs. Practical Discrepancies: A promised result may fail because of false assumptions, poor implementation or changed conditions. Compare those explanations with the evidence rather than automatically treating every failure as a logical contradiction.
  8. Dynamic Social Contexts: Changed conditions can make a policy ineffective or reveal that a principle was stated too broadly. Age or unpopularity alone does not make a claim internally inconsistent.
  9. Conflicting Interpretations: Rival schools can disagree while each remains internally consistent. A contradiction arises within a position only when it commits to the incompatible interpretations together.
  10. Economic Unrealism: An economic claim may conflict with observed constraints. Separate this empirical failure from internal contradiction, which would require the theory itself to affirm incompatible assumptions or outcomes.

Addressing these incoherencies requires rigorous self-critique, openness to empirical evidence, and a willingness to adapt ideological principles to overcome contradictions and enhance coherence.

Gemini response · editorial edition

The following patterns can undermine an ideology, but not all are internal contradictions. Keep inconsistency, unsupported justification, ambiguity and empirical failure distinct:

Logical Fallacies:

  • Circular Reasoning: A claim is supported by a premise whose justification already assumes that claim. Example: “The leader is always right because our doctrine says so; the doctrine is true because the leader guarantees it.”
  • False Dichotomy: This presents only two extreme options, ignoring the possibility of nuances or middle ground. Example: “You are either with us or against us.”
  • Strawman Argument: This misrepresents an opposing argument to make it easier to attack. Example: “Those who disagree with us just want chaos.”

Inconsistent Definitions:

  • Vagueness: A term lacks enough precision for the argument at hand. Different legitimate meanings are not themselves inconsistent; a problem arises when an inference silently changes meanings.
  • Shifting Goalposts: When evidence contradicts claims, the criteria for success are changed to maintain validity. Example: “The prophecy hasn’t happened yet, but it will, you just have to wait longer.”

Conflicting Values:

  • Prioritization Clash: Values can conflict in application without contradiction if the ideology has a defensible way to weigh them. The inconsistency arises when it insists that incompatible demands are both absolute in the same case.
  • Unintended Consequences: A policy can cause the opposite of what was promised. For example, an intervention intended to prevent conflict might instead escalate it. This is an outcome to investigate, not automatically a logical contradiction.

Historical Amnesia:

  • Selective Memory: Only facts supporting the ideology are emphasized, while inconvenient ones are ignored or downplayed. Example: “Ignoring historical instances of violence committed by our group.”
  • Rewriting History: Past events are reinterpreted to fit the narrative of the ideology, often creating historical inaccuracies. Example: “Claiming our group has always been the victim.”

Ignoring Counterarguments:

  • Dismissal without Analysis: Alternative perspectives are automatically rejected without genuine consideration. Example: “Anyone who disagrees is biased or uninformed.”
  • Ad Hominem Attacks: Criticizing individuals rather than addressing their arguments to avoid engaging with valid points. Example: “They just want to stir trouble.”

It’s important to remember that these are just examples, and not all ideologies exhibit all of them. Additionally, there’s often subjectivity involved in identifying inconsistencies, and interpretations can vary. However, being aware of these common patterns can help you assess the internal coherence of any ideology you encounter and encourage critical thinking.

Prompt 4: Create and 8-item quiz based on the discussion above with answers at the end.

Two eight-item quizzes with answer keys

ChatGPT response · editorial edition

Below is an 8-item quiz designed to assess understanding based on the discussion of testing the coherency and veracity of ideological claims, approaches to empirical testing of religious promises, and common internal incoherencies found within ideologies.

Quiz

1. What is a key step in testing the coherency of an ideology?
A) Ignoring counterarguments
B) Evaluating logical consistency
C) Focusing solely on practical implications
D) Avoiding empirical evidence

2. Which of the following is a critical aspect of assessing the veracity of religious claims?
A) Limiting the inquiry to metaphysical claims
B) Comparing the ideology with scientific theories
C) Identifying testable claims
D) Rejecting all untestable claims

3. What type of study could offer insights into the impacts of religious practices on individuals over time?
A) Cross-sectional study
B) Longitudinal study
C) Randomized control trial
D) Theoretical analysis

4. An ideology requires equal treatment under a rule but explicitly exempts its leaders without a relevant justification. This illustrates: A) Ethical consistency B) Inconsistent application of principles C) Logical consistency D) Pragmatic feasibility

5. Which logical fallacy weakens an ideology’s argumentative structure by misrepresenting an opponent’s argument?
A) Straw man argument
B) Appeal to authority
C) Slippery slope argument
D) Ad hominem

6. A gap between an ideology’s theoretical promises and its outcomes when applied in reality illustrates:
A) Utopianism vs. Pragmatism
B) Logical fallacies
C) Historical revisionism
D) Ethical inconsistencies

7. How can ideologies adapt to avoid becoming obsolete over time?
A) By adhering strictly to original principles
B) By ignoring changing social conditions
C) By adapting to changing social, economic, and technological conditions
D) By enforcing a single interpretation of core principles

8. Which approach is encouraged for testing religious promises while respecting believers’ faith?
A) Demanding the abandonment of untestable claims
B) Applying sensitive and respectful inquiry
C) Using aggressive tactics against religious beliefs
D) Focusing exclusively on metaphysical claims

Answers

  1. B) Evaluating logical consistency
  2. C) Identifying testable claims
  3. B) Longitudinal study
  4. B) Inconsistent application of principles
  5. A) Straw man argument
  6. A) Utopianism vs. Pragmatism
  7. C) By adapting to changing social, economic, and technological conditions
  8. B) Applying sensitive and respectful inquiry

Gemini response · editorial edition

Ideology Incoherency Quiz: Test Your Critical Thinking!

Instructions: Identify the reasoning defect or practical problem in each scenario. These are not all strict internal contradictions. Choose the closest answer from the options below.

Answer Options:

  • A. Circular Reasoning
  • B. False Dichotomy
  • C. Strawman Argument
  • D. Vagueness
  • E. Shifting Goalposts
  • F. Conflicting Values
  • G. Unintended Consequences
  • H. Selective Memory
  • I. Rewriting History
  • J. Dismissal without Analysis
  • K. Ad Hominem Attack
  1. The leader claims that the ideology fosters individual freedom, but anyone who questions its rules is labeled a traitor.
  2. The group predicts an apocalypse if their beliefs aren’t adopted, but when it doesn’t happen, they move the goalposts for its arrival.
  3. “You either believe in our teachings completely or you’re rejecting the truth and doomed to suffer.”
  4. Evidence of past violence committed by the group is dismissed as fabricated lies spread by enemies.
  5. Key terms like “justice” and “equality” are used broadly, allowing different interpretations within the group.
  6. A policy intended to reduce conflict instead causes an escalation its advocates did not anticipate.
  7. When records show their group initiated an attack, supporters alter the chronology to portray it as retaliation.
  8. Any attempt to discuss alternative perspectives is shut down with accusations of ignorance and bias.

Answers:

  1. F. Conflicting Values
  2. E. Shifting Goalposts
  3. B. False Dichotomy
  4. H. Selective Memory
  5. D. Vagueness
  6. G. Unintended Consequences
  7. I. Rewriting History
  8. J. Dismissal without Analysis

This quiz helps you identify common inconsistencies within ideologies by recognizing logical fallacies, unclear definitions, conflicting values, and historical manipulation. Remember, critical thinking requires analyzing information from various perspectives and questioning assumptions.

Prompt 5: Provide 15 discussion question relevant to the content above.

Two sets of fifteen discussion questions

ChatGPT response · editorial edition

  1. Evaluating Ideological Coherence: How do logical inconsistencies within an ideology affect its credibility and adherence among its followers?
  2. Empirical Testing of Religious Claims: In what ways can the methodology of empirical research be adapted to respect the subjective and transcendental aspects of religious experiences while still seeking to understand their effects?
  3. The Role of Logical Fallacies: Why are logical fallacies particularly detrimental to the coherence of ideological arguments, and how can individuals be trained to identify and challenge these fallacies?
  4. Utopian Ideals vs. Pragmatic Realities: How can ideologies balance the tension between striving for utopian ideals and acknowledging pragmatic realities without compromising their core principles?
  5. Historical Revisionism and Ideology: How does evidence-based revision of history differ from changing the record to protect a doctrine, and how does each affect credibility?
  6. Ethical Inconsistencies within Ideologies: How do ethical inconsistencies within an ideology impact its followers’ moral decision-making and the ideology’s societal influence?
  7. Theoretical vs. Practical Discrepancies: Explore the challenges ideologies face when there is a significant gap between their theoretical promises and practical outcomes. How can these ideologies be reformed or adapted?
  8. Adapting Ideologies to Changing Social Contexts: Discuss the importance of ideologies adapting to changing social, economic, and technological conditions. Can an ideology remain relevant without such adaptation?
  9. Selective Application of Ideological Principles: How does the selective application of principles within an ideology contribute to internal and external criticisms, and what strategies can be employed to address this issue?
  10. Empirical vs. Metaphysical Claims in Religion: How can the distinction between empirical and metaphysical claims be maintained in discussions about the veracity of religious promises?
  11. Dialogue Between Science and Religion: What are the benefits and challenges of fostering a dialogue between science and religion, especially when it comes to testing the veracity of religious claims?
  12. Contradictory Objectives in Ideologies: How can an ideology resolve internal contradictions between its objectives, and what are the consequences of failing to do so?
  13. Feasibility of Economic Policies within Ideologies: Discuss the impact of economic unrealism on the practical application of ideological policies. How can ideologies ensure their economic policies are both visionary and realistic?
  14. Ethical Foundations and Ideological Coherence: How do the ethical foundations of an ideology contribute to its overall coherence and appeal to potential followers?
  15. Critical Thinking and Ideological Analysis: In what ways can critical thinking and logical analysis be promoted within educational systems to help individuals critically assess the coherency and veracity of ideological claims?

Gemini response · editorial edition

Discussion Questions on Ideology Incoherency:

  1. Can an ideology ever be entirely free of internal inconsistencies? Why or why not?
  2. How do cultural and historical contexts influence the perception of incoherencies within ideologies?
  3. Is it the responsibility of believers within an ideology to identify and address inconsistencies? Should outsiders engage in this process?
  4. What are the ethical considerations involved in analyzing and critiquing inconsistencies within ideologies?
  5. How can we navigate discussions about inconsistencies without resorting to personal attacks or dismissing entire belief systems?
  6. Do inconsistencies necessarily make an ideology harmful or invalid? Explain your reasoning.
  7. Can identifying inconsistencies be a tool for positive change within ideologies? If so, how?
  8. What role does critical thinking play in identifying and evaluating inconsistencies?
  9. Are some ideological practices more likely to conceal contradictions than others? What evidence would support that comparison?
  10. How can we encourage open and respectful dialogue about inconsistencies within our own belief systems and those of others?
  11. What are the potential consequences of ignoring or dismissing inconsistencies within ideologies?
  12. Can inconsistencies ever be a source of strength or adaptability within an ideology? Explain your perspective.
  13. How does the media portray inconsistencies within different ideologies? Is there a bias?
  14. Can humor or satire be effective tools for highlighting inconsistencies within ideologies? Are there risks associated with this approach?
  15. Ultimately, what is the goal of identifying and discussing inconsistencies within ideologies? Do you believe it leads to greater understanding or deeper division?

These questions are designed to stimulate thoughtful discussion and diverse perspectives on the nature of inconsistencies within ideologies. Encourage participants to share their own experiences, beliefs, and reasoning for a richer and more meaningful dialogue.

Future Branches

Where this page naturally expands

Nearby pages in the same branch include The Mindset of the Honest Seeker, Do I need a “worldview”?, What is Truth?, and Packaged vs Eclectic Ideologies; those links are not decorative, but suggested continuations where the pressure of this page becomes sharper, stranger, or more usefully contested.