What must a moral system establish?
The original five prompts, the curator’s six proposed requirements and four proposed refutations are preserved in place. The two edited response tracks examine the demand for objective authority while distinguishing logical consistency, justification, access, responsibility and enforcement.
Original WordPress conversation, April 23, 2024
Highlights · edited summary
- Consistency does not by itself establish moral authority.
- A threat may motivate compliance without explaining why an obligation exists.
- Tests of disagreement and unequal treatment must specify the system’s claims and hold relevant circumstances constant.
Read This First
If this page feels abrupt, start here
These links provide the wider frame, earlier distinction, or branch map that makes the current page easier to enter.
-
Meta-Ethics
Start here if the current page feels compressed: Meta-Ethics gives the broader frame before the argument narrows into the present pressure.
-
Ethics Branch Guide
If this page feels abrupt, start with the Ethics branch guide so the wider map is visible before the close reading begins.
Read This Next
If the page clicked, continue here
These are not just nearby pages. They are the strongest next moves if you want the pressure of this page to keep unfolding.
-
Coherent Moral Systems
Coherent Moral Systems keeps the same branch pressure in view but turns it from a different angle.
-
“Is” vs “Ought”
“Is” vs “Ought” keeps the same branch pressure in view but turns it from a different angle.
-
Meta-Ethics Focus #1
Meta-Ethics Focus #1 keeps the same branch pressure in view but turns it from a different angle.
Prompt 1: What elements are logically necessary to any coherent moral system?
Six proposed requirements under examination
Include the elements in the following list in your assessment:
- Objective Obligation: This would be an obligation that is not merely peer or societal pressure.
- Punishment for Immoral Actions: It seems it would make no sense for there to be an objective moral system if “immorality” had no punishment.
- Access for all Moral Agents: It seems absurd to have a moral system impinge upon the conduct of moral agents if those moral agents have no access to the moral facts they are obligated to conform to.
- Internal Logical Coherence of the Moral System: Logical inconsistency would disqualify any proposed moral system.
- Distinguishable from Emotions: Moral judgments should be based on something other than just emotional dispositions such as abhorrence or compassion.
- Moral Autonomy: Those deemed moral agents under the moral system need to have free will make their own moral choices.
ChatGPT response · editorial edition
The six proposed elements test several different claims. A system can avoid contradiction yet fail to justify its authority, guide action or assign blame fairly. I will assess each requirement against the curator’s stronger target—morality that binds beyond social pressure—without assuming that all six are necessary for logical consistency alone.
- Objective obligation: If a system claims duties that bind independently of approval, it must explain what makes them binding. Merely calling a rule “objective” supplies no explanation. A consistent conventional code can fail this authority test without contradicting itself; rejecting it as insufficiently moral therefore requires the stronger conception of morality stated in the prompt.
- Punishment for immoral actions: Punishment can enforce a norm, but an obligation and a threat are different things. “You ought not betray a friend” does not become contradictory if the betrayal escapes punishment. Conversely, a powerful authority can punish conduct without establishing that it is wrong. The curator’s challenge therefore requires a further argument connecting genuine obligation with deserved or guaranteed punishment. Guilt is neither guaranteed nor a reliable measure of wrongdoing.
- Access for all moral agents: A theory that blames people for violating unknowable requirements owes an account of fairness. Distinguish a rule’s truth, an agent’s opportunity to learn it and culpability for failing to do so. Unavoidable ignorance may excuse an agent even where a theory still judges the act wrong; deliberate avoidance of evidence is a different case.
- Internal logical coherence: Under ordinary classical reasoning, a theory must not require and forbid the same action in the same circumstances and sense without explaining the conflict. Different initial duties need not contradict each other if the theory supplies priorities or distinguishes defeasible reasons from final obligations. Consistency is necessary for this standard of coherence, but a perfectly consistent rule can still be unsupported.
- Distinguishable from emotions: Feeling abhorrence or compassion does not by itself establish the authority claimed for a judgment. Ask how the theory distinguishes warranted responses from prejudice or temporary mood. This preserves the curator’s demand for more than emotional assertion without assuming that every theory giving emotions a role is internally contradictory.
- Moral autonomy: If a theory assigns responsibility, it must say what capacities and control make an agent answerable. That is not yet a proof that libertarian freedom—freedom incompatible with causal determination—is required. Compatibilists offer accounts of responsibility under determinism. The theory must defend its own account rather than move silently between these meanings of free will.
The strongest assessment keeps the tests separate: establish consistency, identify the claimed source of obligation, explain access and responsibility, and justify any sanctions. Passing the first test does not answer the curator’s central challenge about binding authority; failing to include punishment does not alone demonstrate contradiction.
Claude response · editorial edition
The proposed requirements identify serious burdens for a theory claiming objective moral authority. Their logical status differs, however: some concern consistency, others justification, accountability or practical enforcement. Here is an assessment in the original order:
Objective obligation: Necessary for the particular claim that morality binds beyond convention or preference. It is not a logical prerequisite for every consistent ethical framework. An anti-realist must explain what force moral criticism retains; a realist must explain what makes the alleged objective demand authoritative. Neither can settle that dispute by definition alone.
Punishment for Immoral Actions: While punishment may serve as a deterrent and provide incentives to follow moral norms, I don’t believe it is strictly necessary for the internal coherence of a moral system itself. A system could coherently specify moral ideals and obligations without prescribing punishments, which are more practical enforcement mechanisms.
Access for all moral agents: The demand is especially strong where the system assigns blame. Specify whether access means an opportunity for inquiry, reliable guidance or infallible knowledge. A person’s unavoidable inability to discover a requirement raises a culpability problem; it does not automatically show that the requirement is false.
Internal logical coherence: A system must avoid incompatible final requirements under the same conditions, or explain the logic by which it handles them. Arbitrariness and lack of justification are additional defects; neither is identical to formal contradiction.
Distinguishable from emotions: The curator’s challenge is how a feeling could warrant a demand on another person. A theory cannot answer simply by repeating that the feeling is intense. Sentimentalist theories may nevertheless provide standards for assessing emotions, so they require examination rather than dismissal as automatically incoherent.
Moral autonomy: Responsibility requires an account of agency and control. Whether that entails libertarian free will is contested; an account based on reasons-responsive action under determinism is a competing proposal, not a contradiction in terms.
I therefore retain the objection that punishment is not logically necessary, but withdraw the original blanket endorsement of libertarian freedom and objective obligation as conditions of consistency. Those are substantive commitments that must be defended. The curator’s stronger test remains: has the system earned the authority it claims over an agent?
Prompt 2: What proposed moral systems include these necessary elements? List each moral system, and discuss the nature of each necessary element.
Comparing the requirements across moral systems
ChatGPT response · editorial edition
These three systems address the proposed requirements in different ways. Their advocates’ answers are not demonstrations that every requirement has been satisfied. The following comparison keeps the six headings and notes where a theory rejects, qualifies or leaves a burden unresolved.
- Kantian Ethics (Deontological Ethics):
- Objective obligation: Kant grounds duty in rational self-legislation and the categorical imperative, including the test of whether one can will a maxim as universal law. This is his proposed foundation of authority; stating the formula does not settle objections to its derivation or application.
- Punishment: Contrary to the original response, Kant gives a substantial account of criminal punishment. In the Doctrine of Right, section on punishment, guilt for a crime is required; punishment cannot be imposed merely to produce benefits. This juridical account does not mean every ethical lapse must receive a legal penalty.
- Access: Kant presents moral law as available to rational agency, not dependent on specialist revelation. Applying principles to uncertain circumstances still requires judgment; this claim does not establish that every agent reaches every correct verdict.
- Internal Logical Coherence of the Moral System: Kant’s system strives for logical consistency, particularly in the formulation and application of the categorical imperative.
- Distinguishable from emotions: Duty’s authority does not depend on whether we feel inclined to comply. Acting from duty need not involve suppressing every sympathetic feeling; the issue is what grounds the maxim and its moral worth.
- Moral Autonomy: Kant places great importance on autonomy, arguing that moral agents must act according to laws they prescribe to themselves through reason, reflecting true moral freedom.
- Utilitarianism:
- Objective obligation: Classical utilitarianism evaluates conduct by its contribution to overall happiness, impartially considered. Maximizing aggregate welfare is not simply maximizing the number of beneficiaries. The principle supplies a criterion once accepted; why anyone is bound by it remains a justificatory question.
- Punishment for Immoral Actions: Punishment is justified within utilitarianism if it leads to a greater overall good, such as deterrence or rehabilitation.
- Access for all Moral Agents: The basic principles of utilitarianism are simple and widely accessible; however, calculating the greatest good can sometimes be complex and require significant understanding of potential outcomes.
- Internal Logical Coherence of the Moral System: Utilitarianism aims for coherence in its principle of utility maximization, although critics argue about potential conflicts in applying this principle to every situation.
- Distinguishable from Emotions: While utilitarianism considers the welfare and happiness of individuals, it seeks a rational calculation of benefits and harms rather than basing decisions solely on emotional responses.
- Moral autonomy: Agents deliberate about consequences, but their freedom of choice is not automatically an overriding constraint on welfare maximization. A utilitarian must explain the protection given to liberty and how conflicts with aggregate benefit are handled.
- Virtue Ethics:
- Objective obligation: Aristotelian virtue ethics connects virtues with human flourishing. Calling traits virtues does not establish that they are objectively good or translate every virtue into a categorical duty; the account of flourishing must be defended.
- Punishment for Immoral Actions: Less emphasis is placed on punishment and more on cultivating virtues that naturally lead to good actions and discourage immoral behavior.
- Access for all Moral Agents: Moral knowledge comes from the communal and cultural transmission of virtues, as well as personal experience and reflection.
- Internal coherence: Accepting that virtues contribute to a good life is not sufficient to prove consistency. The theory must explain how practical wisdom handles tensions among courage, justice, loyalty and other virtues.
- Distinguishable from emotions: In Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, Book II, virtue involves feeling and acting appropriately. Emotions are trained and assessed, not excluded. The challenge is to justify the standards of appropriateness.
- Moral autonomy: Deliberate choice and practical wisdom matter, but Aristotle’s account should not be equated with Kantian self-legislation. Habituation and education shape an agent’s ability to choose well.
Each of these systems approaches the elements of a coherent moral framework differently, reflecting diverse philosophical foundations and priorities in their conceptualization of ethics.
Claude response · editorial edition
The following four approaches can be compared against the curator’s six requirements. Their proposed foundations remain contestable. The original response omitted punishment from each comparison; that missing criterion is now addressed within each entry.
- Divine Command Theory (based on religions like Christianity, Islam, etc.):
- Objective obligation: Divine command theories ground duties in divine commands. Whether obedience is owed, and whether the commands are arbitrary, remain questions to answer; not every religious ethic is a divine command theory.
Punishment: Some religious accounts add divine sanctions, but commands and punishment are conceptually distinct. Threats alone would establish an incentive, not moral authority. - Access: Proposed routes include revelation, scripture and reason. Unequal exposure, conflicting revelations and interpretive disagreement must be addressed before universal accessibility is established.
- Logical coherence: A perfect, non-contradictory divine source would be relevant if established, but attributing perfection does not resolve apparent conflicts among the commands that humans actually claim to receive.
- Distinguishable from Emotions: Ideally based on divine reason rather than human emotions.
- Moral autonomy: Choosing whether to obey can count as agency, but obedience to another will is not the same as Kantian autonomy. The account must explain freedom and responsibility on its own terms.
- Kantian Deontology:
- Objective obligation: Kant proposes that the categorical imperative expresses rational duty.
Punishment: His juridical account grounds punishment in criminal guilt, rather than utility alone; see the linked primary text in the preceding response. Not every breach of ethical duty is thereby a crime. - Access: Through human rationality and the ability to formulate and understand moral maxims.
- Logical Coherence: Aimed at through Kant’s tests for universalizability and respect for rational agency.
- Distinguishable from Emotions: Kant argued for duty derived from reason over emotional inclinations.
- Moral Autonomy: Humans have rational free will to autonomously legislate moral laws.
- Aristotelian Virtue Ethics:
- Objective obligation: Aristotelian ethics connects virtue to eudaimonia, or human flourishing. This offers a proposed standard of good activity, not a simple catalogue of obligatory commands.
Punishment: Moral education and habituation are central; a virtue-based approach can assess correction by justice and character formation without making guaranteed punishment a condition of every moral judgment. - Access: Through teaching, habituation, and perfecting human reason to discern virtues.
- Logical Coherence: Sought by grounding in an objective account of human nature and purposes.
- Distinguishable from emotions: Properly educated emotions are part of virtue, alongside practical wisdom. A feeling’s intensity does not establish its appropriateness.
- Moral Autonomy: Humans can rationally develop virtuous characters through habit and choice.
- Utilitarianism (Bentham, Mill):
- Objective obligation: Classical utilitarianism directs impartial promotion of overall happiness or well-being. Its authority still needs justification.
Punishment: Consequences such as prevention and rehabilitation must justify the suffering imposed. Mill also examines internal and external motives for compliance in Utilitarianism, Chapter III; motivation should not be confused with proving a moral principle. - Access: Through empirical study of what produces happiness/suffering and using reason to calculate best outcomes.
- Logical Coherence: Attempted by grounding it in a simple, comprehensive principle of utility maximization.
- Distinguishable from Emotions: Aimed at considering overall impartial utility, not just individual sentiments.
- Moral autonomy: Agents can reason about effects, but that capacity is different from treating each person’s choices as inviolable. Utilitarian accounts must explain when liberty constrains action or is protected because of its consequences.
These are proposed answers, not certificates of coherence or objectivity. They differ over whether punishment is fundamental, what access requires and what autonomy means. The curator’s comparison is most useful when each system must state and defend its answer to every requirement instead of receiving credit merely for using the same vocabulary.
Prompt 3: The following are proposed ways to refute the coherence of a moral system. Elaborate on each and provide any evaluative criteria of your own.
Four proposed refutations and further tests
- Disagreement on specific moral facts: If a moral system is truly accessible to all agents under that moral system, there should be no disagreement on what is moral.
- Temporal inconsistency in the application of morality: For example, if slavery is morally wrong now, it should have always been morally wrong.
- Regional inconsistency in the application of morality: For example, if slavery is morally wrong for Group A, it should be wrong for Group B.
- Inconsistent punishments: If the degree of punishment administered for the degree of a moral offense is inconsistent across individuals, the system fails.
ChatGPT response · editorial edition
Each proposed refutation targets a claim worth testing. The key is to distinguish contradiction in the principles from failure in application, and to compare cases with the same morally relevant features. Here are the four challenges and additional criteria in their original order:
- Disagreement on Specific Moral Facts:
- Elaboration: Disagreement puts pressure on a claim of clear, universal access, especially among careful, equally informed agents. Access alone, however, does not imply infallibility: people can have access to arithmetic and still make mistakes. Disagreement therefore needs an argument linking it to the theory’s specific accessibility claim.
- Evaluative criteria: Identify the exact disputed proposition, equalize factual information where possible, and ask what procedure the system supplies to resolve the dispute. If it promises certain agreement under those conditions, persistent disagreement is a direct problem. Otherwise it may indicate weak guidance or justification rather than logical contradiction.
- Temporal Inconsistency in the Application of Morality:
- Elaboration: The slavery example challenges a theory that changes its verdict merely because an era changes while the relevant coercion and harms remain the same. Distinguish a change in moral truth from a change in people’s recognition of it. A population’s former approval does not show that slavery was then justified.
- Evaluative criteria: Compare the same action under the same relevant conditions. Demand an explanation of any claimed difference and test it independently of the desired verdict. New information may correct an earlier judgment; “it was accepted then” alone does not answer the curator’s objection.
- Regional Inconsistency in the Application of Morality:
- Elaboration: If the same treatment is condemned for Group A but permitted for Group B solely because of group identity, a theory claiming impartial authority owes a justification. Different practical rules can nevertheless follow from one principle where relevant circumstances differ.
- Evaluative criteria: Swap group labels while holding coercion, interests and other relevant facts fixed. If the verdict changes, require a reason that does not merely repeat the favored group’s status. Do not let an appeal to “culture” conceal the same exploitation the theory condemns elsewhere.
- Inconsistent Punishments:
- Elaboration: Unequal punishment for relevantly equivalent offenses challenges a system’s claim to equal justice. Distinguish what the theory requires from what officials actually do: corrupt enforcement can violate a coherent rule rather than reveal a contradiction within it.
- Evaluative criteria: Compare culpability, intent, knowledge, coercion and harm, then ask whether the stated rationale explains the difference. A theory must also justify punishment itself. Harm alone cannot determine every penalty: an accident and an intentional attack can cause equal damage while differing in responsibility.
Additional Evaluative Criteria:
- Practical Applicability: Beyond theoretical coherence, a moral system should be practically applicable in everyday situations. It must offer clear guidance that can be realistically followed by its moral agents.
- Flexibility and Adaptability: While maintaining core principles, a moral system should be adaptable enough to address new ethical challenges as societies evolve and new technologies emerge.
- Comprehensive Scope: The moral system should cover a broad range of ethical issues, providing guidance on various aspects of human conduct without leaving significant gaps.
These tests assess different strengths. Contradictory requirements, unsupported authority, inaccessible guidance and unfair enforcement are serious but distinct defects. A precise critique states which defect has been shown and what further claim remains unproved.
Claude response · editorial edition
The four challenges can expose weaknesses, but none should be treated as an automatic refutation without specifying the theory’s claims and the circumstances being compared.
Disagreement on moral facts: Persistent informed disagreement may undermine claims of easy or reliable access. It does not by itself establish that no truth exists. Ask what access was promised, whether the disputants satisfy its conditions and how the theory diagnoses error without simply favoring its supporters.
Temporal inconsistency: A theory cannot defend slavery merely by pointing to its historical acceptance while claiming standards independent of acceptance. Hold relevant features fixed and distinguish moral truth from past belief about it. Changing knowledge can explain corrected verdicts without proving that truth itself changed.
Regional inconsistency: Demand the same treatment of relevantly equivalent cases. Regional differences in circumstances can matter; the label of the region alone supplies no justification. A theory openly relativizing morality may be coherent yet fail the curator’s stronger requirement of objective authority.
Inconsistent punishments: Compare cases with equivalent culpability and relevant circumstances, and distinguish the rule from its enforcement. A difference may reveal partiality, an undisclosed criterion or abuse. Determine which before declaring the underlying principles contradictory.
Some additional criteria I would propose:
Handling moral dilemmas: Ask how conflicting reasons relate to final obligations. A theory may offer priority rules, permit several choices or acknowledge a genuine dilemma. Failure to give a unique answer is a limitation of guidance, not automatically a contradiction.
Justifying foundations: Require reasons for basic premises and for their claimed authority. An arbitrary foundation can be consistent; this criterion therefore tests justification as well as coherence.
Action-guidingness: The system should provide clear enough guidance on how to act in the world to be practically applicable as a way of life, not just a theoretical construct.
The result should be a diagnosis: what contradicts what, which claim lacks support, and which agents cannot apply the rule? This keeps the curator’s challenge sharp while avoiding the mistaken inference that every practical difficulty proves a logical inconsistency.
Prompt 4: Create a 10-item quiz on the entire thread above.
Two ten-question quizzes with final answers
ChatGPT response · editorial edition
Here’s a 10-item quiz based on our discussion above about moral systems and their coherence, followed by the list of answers:
Quiz Questions
- What is the purpose of objective obligations in a moral system?
- How does Kant’s account of criminal punishment differ from a purely utilitarian justification?
- According to utilitarianism, how should the punishments for immoral actions be determined?
- What principle does virtue ethics focus on to guide moral behavior?
- Why is access to moral knowledge important for all moral agents in a coherent moral system?
- How does Kantian ethics ensure that its moral judgments are distinguishable from emotions?
- What is a potential problem with utilitarianism’s approach to calculating the greatest good?
- What does the argument regarding “temporal inconsistency in the application of morality” criticize about some moral systems?
- How might regional inconsistency challenge the universality of a moral system?
- What criteria can be used to evaluate the fairness of punishments in a moral system?
Quiz Answers
- They purport to bind independently of social pressure or personal approval. Their existence and authority still require justification.
- Kant requires criminal guilt and rejects using punishment merely to produce benefits; a utilitarian justification assesses the consequences of imposing it.
- Punishments should lead to a greater overall good, such as deterrence or rehabilitation.
- The development of good character traits (virtues) that enable individuals to live and act morally.
- It matters especially to fair blame: a system must distinguish unavoidable ignorance from culpable failure to learn. Accessibility alone does not guarantee correct judgment.
- It grounds duty in rational principles rather than inclination; this does not require the absence of every sympathetic feeling.
- The complexity in calculating the effects of actions and determining the true maximization of happiness can be problematic.
- It challenges changes of verdict based merely on the era while relevant facts remain fixed. Changes in belief or information need not be changes in moral truth.
- Unjustified differences between relevantly equivalent cases challenge universal authority; differences supported by relevant circumstances need not do so.
- A justified rationale, proportionality, and consistent treatment of equivalent cases, including intent, knowledge, coercion and harm—not harm alone.
Claude response · editorial edition
10-Item Quiz on Moral System Coherence
- Which proposed element is challenged as unnecessary for internal consistency because enforcement and obligation are different questions?
- According to the discussion, which proposed moral system attempts to derive objective obligations from the commands of God?
- True or False: Kantian Deontology aims to ground objective moral duties in the Categorical Imperative derived from reason.
- Which moral theory is focused on cultivating virtuous character traits oriented towards human flourishing (eudaimonia)?
- What criterion does classical utilitarianism propose for judging actions?
- Does access to moral inquiry logically guarantee agreement on every moral judgment? Explain.
- What must be held fixed when comparing moral verdicts across different times?
- When would a regional difference in verdict challenge a system’s claim to impartial authority?
- What should a theory explain when moral reasons pull toward incompatible actions?
- Why should a theory’s foundations be tested for justification as well as consistency?
Answers:
- Punishment for Immoral Actions
- Divine Command Theory
- True
- Aristotelian Virtue Ethics
- Maximize overall utility/happiness/well-being impartially considered
- No. Access need not imply infallibility. Persistent informed disagreement nevertheless puts pressure on a theory’s specific claims about reliable or certain access.
- The relevant features of the act and circumstances; distinguish changes in belief from changes in truth.
- When relevantly equivalent cases receive different verdicts without a justified difference beyond group or regional identity.
- How competing reasons relate to final obligations: through priorities, permitted alternatives or an acknowledged dilemma.
- A consistent set of premises can still be arbitrary or unsupported; consistency alone does not establish binding authority.
Prompt 5: Provide 15 discussion questions relevant to the content above.
Two sets of fifteen discussion questions
ChatGPT response · editorial edition
Here are 15 discussion questions that delve into the themes and ideas discussed about moral systems and their coherence:
- How do objective obligations differ from societal norms and personal beliefs in shaping a moral system?
- Can a moral system be considered valid if it incorporates emotional responses into its framework? Why or why not?
- Discuss the role of punishment in moral systems. Is it always necessary for maintaining order and morality?
- How do Kantian ethics and utilitarianism differ in their approach to moral autonomy?
- What are the challenges in ensuring that all moral agents have access to the same moral knowledge?
- How might temporal inconsistencies in moral judgments impact the credibility of a moral system?
- In what ways can regional inconsistencies in moral applications challenge the universality of moral principles?
- Discuss the importance of logical consistency within a moral system. Can a system function effectively with some level of inconsistency?
- How does virtue ethics address the issue of moral autonomy compared to deontological and consequentialist theories?
- What are the implications of inconsistent punishments within a moral system? How does this affect perceptions of justice?
- How can a moral system adapt to new ethical challenges without compromising its foundational principles?
- Discuss the importance of distinguishing moral judgments from emotions. Can emotions ever play a positive role in ethical decision-making?
- How does the concept of free will interact with different moral systems, especially concerning moral autonomy?
- What role do cultural differences play in the interpretation and application of universal moral principles?
- How could a moral system ensure fairness and objectivity in its application across different societies and historical periods?
These questions are designed to encourage deep thinking and debate about the foundational aspects and practical applications of moral systems, highlighting the complexities and nuances involved in ethical theory and practice.
Claude response · editorial edition
Here are 15 discussion questions relevant to the content on coherent moral systems:
- What do you think is the strongest argument for why an objective moral obligation is necessary for a coherent moral system?
- Can a moral system be truly coherent if it allows for punishment mechanisms that are not logically derived from the system’s principles? Why or why not?
- How can a moral system ensure epistemic access and understanding for all moral agents? What are the potential barriers?
- In what ways might a moral system’s lack of logical coherence manifest itself in the real world? Provide some examples.
- Should emotions play any role at all in a coherent moral framework or must it be entirely grounded in reason? Discuss both perspectives.
- Why is the criterion of moral autonomy and free will considered crucial for many moral philosophers? What are the implications if humans lack free will?
- Which proposed moral system (divine command, Kantian, Aristotelian, utilitarian) do you find most coherent and convincing? Explain your reasoning.
- How might one respond to the “disagreement on moral facts” objection regarding a moral system’s purported accessibility?
- Is the “temporal inconsistency” critique a fatal problem for moral systems, or can moral truths legitimately evolve over time? Discuss both sides.
- Should a coherent moral system allow for any regional variability in its application, or must it be universally consistent across all contexts?
- In your view, how significant is the “inconsistent punishments” objection for assessing a moral system’s coherence?
- How well do our existing moral, legal and political systems fare in resolving moral dilemmas that pit values against each other?
- What are some examples of moral foundations or premises that could be considered incoherently arbitrary in grounding a moral system?
- Is the criterion of providing clear “action-guidance” essential for a moral theory, or can a coherent system remain more abstract?
- Are there any additional criteria you would propose for assessing the coherence of moral systems beyond what has been discussed?
Future Branches
Where this page naturally expands
Nearby pages in the same branch include Coherent Moral Systems, “Is” vs “Ought”, Meta-Ethics Focus #1, and Meta-Ethics Focus #2; those links are not decorative, but suggested continuations where the pressure of this page becomes sharper, stranger, or more usefully contested.